Sen. Chris Van Hollen D-MD will challenge Schumer for Senate Majority Leader

Erased upon seeing mod note.

Moderating:

Please note the mod note just above your post. This is not the thread for this discussion.

Yeah I started writing before it was there …

Thanks for the erasure.

Nvm… Mods took care of it

At the very least, I hope Van Hollen’s challenge results in a vote within the caucus on getting rid of the filibuster, where who voted which way is made known. This is a big enough deal that Senators shouldn’t be able to hide which way they lean on this, so their constituents on either side can put pressure on them if they choose.

Since I’m a Maryland resident, I at least know where one of my Senators stands on the filibuster. :slight_smile:

Seems to me the filibuster is to the Dems’ advantage until January. Be patient and don’t give the lame ducks any ideas.

Any removal of the filibuster before Dems win the House/Senate/Presidency is an enormous strategic blunder.

Any vote where you can’t get 4 Republicans will be vetoed, any vetoed legislation earns you zero brownie points from progressives, but it will be plastered all over every bit of print media that Democrats are dangerous norm subverting radicals.

Dems need to govern with 2029 in mind. That doesn’t mean not trying to pass good legislation (We got a lot of great bills signed after 2006), but that means pressuring Republicans, not just doing procedural changes to impress progressive influencers (who will give Dems zero credit anyway)

Why is it a blunder to remove a limitation that only applies to one party?

And afterwards, even. The Dems will not have control of congress forever.

Good point.

If you don’t know that the filibuster has prevented some horrible legislation over the 24-25 legislative session, you suffer from a serious lack of knowing ball.

Let the majority govern. Let the American people see what they actually voted for. If Republicans have both houses, let the American people see what they granted them. Same goes for the Democrats. They’re elected to govern under their vision, not elected for gridlock. Maybe preserve some version of the old talking filibuster to slow down major or controversial changes, but ultimately those elected should be able to govern.

I’m perfectly content to break the filibuster if we get something out of it. Particularly if it ends up reshaping the court. I just don’t want to end it for the sake of ending it to satiate a group of people who are constitutionally insatiable.

But to me the best bet is to aim for 60 or more senate seats in 2029 with the hope we can make some massive changes with a supermajority (expand scotus, expand the house, add PR and DC as states) and use breaking the filibuster as a backup, which means not committing to breaking the filibuster until we have to, so we have a better chance of winning over IA/SC/KS voters.

May I suggest that the filibuster, while related to this, would deserve its own thread?

What we get out of eliminating the filibuster is eliminating the filibuster. Even if the Republicans didn’t just ignore it, it’s fundamentally undemocratic, and plays to the party that wants government to be dysfunctional and against the party that wants government to do good.

And Puerto Rico absolutely needs to be admitted as a state, but there’s no way we’d be able to get a Constitutional amendment for DC.

I’m open to that strategy, but at this point I’d prefer to do it now. Even if Trump can still veto everything, it sets the stage for what we actually want to accomplish, and takes away the filibuster as a major '28 campaign issue. Pull the bandaid off now and we don’t have to worry about it later. 60 votes would be great, but would mean reaching for the rhetorical stars would be much harder - just 1 Dem not willing to expand (or otherwise majorly reform) SCOTUS, or add states, and suddenly we accomplish very little (without SCOTUS reform I doubt we can do much of anything)… and then the focus of debate becomes the filibuster itself instead of actual legislation. Do it now and we don’t have to worry about it later.

I understand that my view is not very likely right now.

They have. OTOH the GOP has shown it will change the filibuster when it needs to. But yes, it has been valuable during the last couple years.

Justice, etc nominations already- thanks to McConnell- can not be filibustered.

Now that we have the senate, we do not need to pack the Court. My guess is that a couple of the worst Justices will go out in the next couple of years, but trump can not replace them with like minded Justices. Then in 2028, with a Dem president (hopefully) we can fill with better choices.

I totally agree.

Van Hollen says that Schumer doesn’t have the votes he is saying publicly he has:

https://talkingpointsmemo.com/live-blog-update/van-hollen-says-he-has-a-path-to-get-to-majority-leader

A different article at TPM contains hugely useful advice from Theda Skocpol.

Will the Democrats now rise to the occasion of building on this through at least two more national elections? To do so, they must avoid “progressive” versus “centrist” fights, stop passing huge kitchen sink bills no one understands and instead pass one at a time popular measures and force Trump to veto them, and keep in touch with their voters everywhere.

The only way to do this is to can the filibuster. That’s the major reason these omnibus bills exist today. Start with bills so major they must be passed and then add a nebula of wish list bills that are hated by many but have to be accepted to get the real work done.

Many people have suggested that the Democrats use the strategy of codifying policies that a majority of Americans want and send those bills to Trump to either pass or veto to the displeasure even of many Republicans. At present, Republican Senators can filibuster those bills creating a miasma of slime around them. A plain up-and-down vote cuts through the toxic fog.

Van Hollen advocates for ending the filibuster. I’m totally in support of that. The best hope is that he gets Schumer to agree in return for dropping his run and displaying party unity at the end of the vote.

I very much endorse this strategy.