Sen. Chris Van Hollen D-MD will challenge Schumer for Senate Majority Leader

If that’s the purpose of this challenge, sure–disappointing, but sure. But at this point I see no reason to think that Schumer is likelier to be telling the truth than van Hollen about who has the votes. Schumer has a massive advantage as the incumbent, but I’m not sure he has a record of political courage and integrity that overshines van Hollen’s.

Of course he does.

But that line of discussion concedes an interesting point: you don’t talk about how the other guy isn’t really winning unless the other guy actually is winning.

A winner talks mostly about their own strength of position. If you’re focused on the other guy, you’ve implicitly acknowledged you’re not winning right now.

Conversely, if Schumer doesn’t have the votes, he might be trying to pressure the fence riders by sending signals that he does, in fact, have them, and thus they better get in line or there will be consequences.

Right now it’s just posturing, and with a secret ballot, it’s hard to know for sure what the count is right now. IMO if Schumer really is trying to get the leader vote moved up rather than as scheduled, that’s a sign of weakness - he thinks time is working against him.

The filibuster helped during the recent years when the GOP controlled Congress. Who is to say it will not happen again?

Or you talk about how the other guy isn’t really winning if the other guy is insisting he’s winning as a tactic to scare you into withdrawing from the contest.

I think everyone acknowledges that Schumer is the King of the Hill. The question is whether it’s worth the attempt to unseat the King.

I am 100% about that attempt. I think there’s very little harm in it, and even if Schumer stays in power, it’s important that that’s not a foregone conclusion.

97% of Indivisible chapter leaders are backing Van Hollen.

Right, because that’s the way the Senate chooses its leadership. Always has, always will. /s

Had that been what I was suggesting , your sarcasm would be on point.

Yes, if the Puerto Ricans want statehood. My understanding is that that’s not a settled question.

The question is one Puerto Ricans on the island have voted on several times before. Once again, they have voted in favor of becoming a state, this time with 57 percent in favor.

That’s two years ago. There’s since been two years of Latins who are also Americans watching their ethnicity be mistreated wherever and whenever possible. Often to cheering crowds of white Americans. That might sour some of them on joining our broken (and now perhaps maybe a little bit beginning to try to heal) polity.

And the results are not really quite what that breezy headline suggests.

First off, turnout on this question was 63% of registered voters. So 63% of 58% = 36% of registered voters voted for statehood. As well, registered voters are not all persons who are eligible to vote. I’m not readily finding stats on that, but it’s another non-trivial number of adults who did not express a preference in any direction. Further diluting the percentage of the potential electorate who did express a preference for statehood.

Secondly, the referendum was deliberately designed as a stacked deck with 3 choices. None of which was maintain the status quo. Given that the number of registered voter abstentions is materially greater than the number of votes for statehood, a darn good argument can be made that the abstentions were the votes for status quo. And that’s the choice that won the 4-way plurality.

There’s a lot more to learn here: 2024 Puerto Rican status referendum - Wikipedia.

Is there any reason to suspect that this will go much different than Jeffires?

Google says that four of the incoming Senators have said they are supporting him so that’s five since he will presumably vote for himself.

Schumer has sixteen including himself.

The vote will be on December 1st and Klobuchar will have resigned by then to become Governor. So the winner needs 28.

I think Schumer wins easily. Half of the people who aren’t supporting Schumer would probably be less happy with a more vocally progressive alternative.

I think most of this was people ginning up drama after the lull from after the election. They miss being outraged while Trump is being quiet and once the next stupid thing happens they’ll forget all about this storyline.

No.

Not really.

Slotkin endorsed CVH which does feel like a more serious development. She’s exactly the kind of centrist I’d expect to steer clear of a starry/eyed progressive. Not sure what it means, but it’s not nothing.

I think it means that Schumer doesn’t have all the votes he’s saying he does. Endorsing Van Hollen carries risks, since if he loses there will likely be consequences for those Senators who supported him (less preferable committee assignments, and the like). The freshmen might get a pass since they campaigned on opposing Schumer, but Slotkin is not a freshman.

She said on Nov 10 that she wouldn’t vote for Schumer, in a statement she made along with Bernie. So this isn’t exactly a new development.

Some people are giving Schumer the credit he deserves:

I maintain he deserves some credit, will be Senate Majority Leader, and should soon after he wins the election announce that this will be his final term in the Senate.

To me it is both true that he has done a fine and fairly thankless job, and, at the risk of being accused of agism, that it is time to have a new generation step into leadership roles. 2028 is, hopefully, the beginning of a new era, and a good time to hand the torch on.