there was a typical “diner” near where I used to work. Quotes because they were a reasonably modern establishment, but the menu was obviously intended to replicate a 1940-50 diner. Actually really good food.
One day, me and a co-worker…nice guy but hopelessly stupid…go there for lunch. Service was fine, food up to the usual great standard etc. But the witress doesn’t bring our check. I’m facing the kitchen, so I signal her several times. Each time, I get the “Sure thing, give me a second and I’ll be right there” signal back.
Finally, after like 10 minutes, we decide to go to the register (at this place you normally take the check your waitress brings you up to the register to pay) and ask for our check, as we need to be getting back to work (I’m pretty sure we had a meeting schedualed).
Waitress stops us on our way to the register and appologizes profusly…“I just don’t know what happened, the kitchen must have lost your order…it will be up in a few seconds!”
“Ummmmm, we got our food…it was great…we just needed our check”
“…oh…Well, let me box them up and you can have them for dinner…don’t tell the manager or I’ll get in trouble.”
“Ummm, well, good as your food is, it would be kind of overkill to have the same thing for lunch and dinner”
“No, please, I’ll get in trouble”
Note, this is a 40 something, very efficient waitress, not some highschool girl who just THINKS she is going to get in trouble.
“OK…I guess we can trade boxes (fortunatly had not ordered same thing)”
Waitress starts boxing up our bonus meals.
Manager sees her doing it, and inquires.
Can’t hear animated explaination.
Manager brings us our boxes, appolgizes, and comps our meal…Ummm, make that
two meals. each.
So the choice is, Take the two free meals (each) OR get thenice, matronly, waitress ( peering fearfully around the corner) in trouble…now both for screwing up, AND (we assume) lying to the owner about it.
So, we walked out with our boxes feeling kind of dirty.
I went back there a couple of times, but it always felt wierd.
Now the truly ethical thing to do would have been to refuse the waitresses offer to box the meals.
But she BEGGED!