So am I a thieving dog or a lucky one?

I’m pretty sure this general subject has been covered in GD in the past few months, but I can’t find the thread and, anyway, I’m less interested in a debate than I am in general reactions.

I sit here typing on my new laptop, a replacement for my eleven-year-old Mac, the beloved and much-missed Calliope. (Yes, I name my computers. They’re people, damn it. Calliope was preceded by Skipper, who was preceded by Roberstein.) For the past few years I’d been using Calliope just for writing and doing any web browsing at work or the library. But Calliope’s printer finally wore out, and the old girl is so old she can’t be hooked to a new one. So to the dark, lonely hall closet she went

So, with a shudder and a feeling of guilt, I move to a new Toshiba laptop, Gay Deceiver. Nothing all that special, as my primary use is still for writing. But it does have an internet connection thingie. (Yes, I use the word thingie. It’s a technical term we writers use. It means "high-tech device with an irritating acronym for a name that I can’t remember this instant and don’t feel like looking up.)

So I hook Miss Gay Deceiver up, buy the appropriate widgets so I can get started on setting up the Internet connectionget set to call Time Warner to come out and set me up for Road Runner. While I’m thumbing through the phone book, though, I notice a little message in the taskbar. It says “Wireless network connection. Speed 54.0 Mbps. Signal strength very good.”

But how is this possible? I wonder. I’m cheap. I haven’t paid for any sort of broadband connection, wireless or otherwise. And because my apartment building is converting to condos, which are selling slowly, I’m almost the only person on this floor; my only neighbor is a raging technophobe who thinks computers are agents of the Beast and IP addesses are its mark.

Then it hits me. I live downtown. There’s a hotel attached to this building; I’ve sometimes passed through its lobby, and it advertises Business Class Roadrunner connections for all its guests.

I check the wireless connection control panel to see what’s up. And I discover that I do not, in fact, have a wireless internet connection for free.

That is, I don’t have ONE. Or two. Or three.

I have four.

Because there’s another hotel across the street, you see, who also provides such a connection. And City Hall, across another street, has wireless. And a third hotel across the street from Court Square.

And none of them seem to require any sort of encryption key to get in.

For a few minutes I try the connection out. Standard web pages? Check. Access streaming video? Check? Download real video files with the Wonder Woman openng sequence, or watch Evanescence videos, or German scat porn? Check, check, and jeez that’s gross, Cartman, your mother SUCKS!

Being a minister’s son, I immediately feel another pang of guilt. Isn’t this STEALING? But another part of me disagrees. After all, I didn’t do ANYTHNG but turn the computer one. I didn’t hack into anyone’s system surreptitiously. They–the hotels–are being either careless or generous; I’m not being dishonest–am I?

So should I pay Road Runner for the service? Or treat it like sunlight streaming through my window, as it’ll come through whether I do anything or not?

Well, troopers?

So it’s a male computer?

Cartman’s mom does Evanescence videos? Ewwww, I thought she had better taste than that!

As to your question, if the hotels don’t require a password, they’re basically giving the service away to anyone within range. However, if you have any problems, you don’t have any right to bitch about the service. If you get your own wireless connection, you can encrypt it so only you can use it. You’ll probably get better bandwidth that way, too.

I kinda look at it like this…if someone was giving a concert nearby, and you could hear the music from your apartment, would you be stealing for listening? Nope!

The hotel has the option of securing their network and giving the code only to guests. They have failed to do this. I don’t see a reason why you shouldn’t take advantage of their generosity.

Or you could make sure you alway log in using City Hall’s connection and know you’re helping pay for it through your taxes.

I guess I just feel that if they didn’t want anyone accessing it who wasn’t supposed to, they’d secure it.

If it makes you feel better, you can always stop in the lobby bar and have a drink from time to time.

They are not paying any more for you to be on the internet, you are not hurting anything so good on ya.

By the way the last place I lived provided free wireless internet throughout the downtown area and was expanding to some residential areas as well, so who knows free internet may be on its way. Well not entirely free, I am sure the taxpayers are footing the bill somehow, but it has the illusion of being free. :wink:

Actually I listen to concerts for free all the time, as I live in downtown Memphis and they have concerts in, say, Tom Lee Park and Mud Island that I can overhear. Unfortunately I’m usually trying to sleep then.

We had a long discussion of the subject in this thread. The conclusion was that it is in fact illegal to use someone else’s wireless network without authorization, despite the analogy of the concert you can hear from your living room, or the argument that the wireless network could have been encrypted had the operator chosen to do so.

Sounds to me like you already know the answer Mr. Pang of Guilt. Legal, not legal; ethical or not ethical, you personally feel guilty. I say you go with your gut until one of those four providers lets you know it’s okay.

I’m not lily white here, having received without asking for a particular premium service. I’m too afraid to say exactly what, since according to the commercials, you’re sentenced to something like a million years in a Turkish prison, they burn your house down and salt the soil, then draw and quarter your elderly parents, if you’re caught.

Dewey, thanks much for the link. I couldn’t find that previous thread.

Explain situation to all 4 sources and see if it is okay to use theri bandwidth. If any say yes than you a very lucky. If not you will be notifying them of a potential problem and being very honest.