This pretty much sums up my thinking. Bush’s boys were really gungho for war even before they were in office.
It was pretty major in PNAC.
This pretty much sums up my thinking. Bush’s boys were really gungho for war even before they were in office.
It was pretty major in PNAC.
Cheney was pretty much the leader of the Neocons, so that adds up. As I recall, he was one of those in Poppa Bush’s Cabinet that was against the stopping in Desert Storm. He wanted to topple Hussein back then.
He was the chief architect of the War on Terror and Iraq War.
There was also a very practical consideration. The WTC towers were very, very easy to hit. Trying to hit a specific building on the ground, say the White House, is a bit of a trick. Just finding it visually would have been a bit difficult under the conditions that prevailed.
Yeah, that certainly made sense at the time.
Except President George H.W. Bush and many other advisors thought it would destabilize the Middle East and so they stopped having crippled Iraq’s military and freed Kuwait.
Yeah, that was the proffered explanation anyhow. Everyone knew that was bullshit. All of the guys returning from that war were pissed off. “We’ll have to go back, dammit” was the universal refrain.
Am I missing something?
Was there possibly some warning that something was possibly up above baseline threat levels? It’s possible.
In any case were there constant what ifs being played out? I would be shocked if there wasn’t. Even if the specific scope of the attack wasn’t gamed out.
And?
I agree 100%. They knew SOMETHING was about to happen, but had no idea when, how, or where.
I saw an interview with actor James Woods on a late night talk show a while after the fact, and he said that a few months earlier, he believes he was on a commercial flight with several of the hijackers, and didn’t say why he thought this, but he had a feeling they were going to hijack THAT plane, and brought this to the attention of a flight attendant. She said the crew all felt the same way themselves, although thankfully it didn’t happen then.
Except they didn’t have to go back. Bush decided to send them back even though they didn’t have to.
That sounds absolutely like multiple layers of self-reinforcing confirmation bias. Boil it down to the actual facts, and what you’re left with is “James Woods was on a flight that wasn’t hijacked”.
LOL. Yeah, that’s a distinction without a difference. They were pissed off because.. they knew they would have to go back. And that’s what happened. Q.E.D.
The difference is, once again: they didn’t have to go back. Going into Iraq was something the Bush admin did because they wanted to anyway, Iraq had nothing to do with the 9/11 attacks. It was pretty much the definition of taking your eye off the actual problem and just fucking things up.
Why did they have to go back?
I am not sure about that- cite? I mean the WTC was on their hit list anyway.
I had heard that the Intelligence community knew something was up. But nothing actionable or specific.
Right.
Global U.S. domination
Various parts of the intelligence community had pieces of the puzzle but because of the way they were funded (all competing for the same funds), no one shared information with each other. There is nothing to say that they would have necessarily figured the whole thing out if they did share but after 9/11 there was no longer any choice in the matter. Now they all share with each other. Of course, in the wake of 9/11 they no longer had to worry about funding.
My only problem with that anecdote is that James Woods is a nutbar and I wouldn’t believe him if he told me the sky was blue. Vague feelings of uneasiness from an unstable individual are worth less than nothing to me.
I don’t believe this is accurate, or at best, only partly true. There was “planning” going on, yes, but not as a response to anything. For all practical purposes the presidential briefing was ignored. Disconnects between government agencies that could have built a more coherent picture of what the would-be hijackers were planning were allowed to fester.
One must remember that one of the guiding doctrines of the Bush regime was established by PNAC – the Project for a New American Century – of which Dick Cheney was a founding member and other high-ranking officials in the Bush administration like Paul Wolfowitz were active members. A fundamental pillar to its hawkish right-wing policies was establishing American hegemony around the world, especially in the oil-rich Middle East.
One of the PNAC policy documents stated that all-out action on this front would be politically difficult to justify without a Pearl Harbor type trigger event. 9/11 was just such an event, which I imagine must have secretly delighted the likes of Cheney, Rumsfeld, and Wolfowitz. While the subsequent attack on Afghanistan and the Taliban was justified, the subsequent invasion of Iraq – which had nothing at all to do with 9/11 – was an attempt to exploit this trigger event in pursuit of PNAC goals.
I’d also guess that even if there were warnings 9/11 was going to happen, an intelligence community/agency must be drowning in such warnings at all time, a deluge of legit and not-legit warnings. For every 9/11 that got through, there must be many that were foiled.
And is that all they did - play out some “what ifs”? Doesn’t it raise the question of why they didn’t do anything else?
Bill Clinton has said that he gave the new administration a blueprint for how to handle Bin Laden. There were people sounding the alarm.
It’s shocking to me if the response to that was to play out some possible responses without making much of an effort to thwart anything.
Do you think it was because they felt they had no power to stop what was an inevitability? Or an actual ignorance of the danger, despite the warnings? Or something more malicious - “let’s let this play out; in the meantime, let’s plan out some possible responses.”
I’ve read the same. It fed a lot of conspiracy thinking 20 some years ago.
I just wonder if these neocons felt it was just a matter of time before they got their “Pearl Harbor type trigger”. I can say that I was reading a lot of criticism of American foreign policy by Noam Chomsky at the time of 9/11, which included predictions of blowback against the U.S. So a terrorist attack on U.S. soil wasn’t inconceivable when it happened.
Worked pretty well, too! To this day, there are people who conflate Osama bid Laden with Saddam Hussein and believe our totally unjustified and entirely gratuitous invasion of Iraq was in response to 9/11.
While I don’t believe any specifics of 9/11 were known, I do think the controlling faction in the Bush II regime (aforementioned Cheney/Wolfowitz, e.g.) intended to exploit any big crisis to further their PNAC goals. And they did.