Thanks for your insight. Human interactions and behavior are so complicated!
Yes, by “being in drag all the time” I was referring to Lisa wanting to wear sundresses, not Mollie. I should have been more clear. But when I think of drag I think of the whole female getup, cranked to 11. So that’s probably not the best way to describe it.
It sounds like the correct term would be gender non-conforming man.
I’m an “anything goes” sort of person when it comes to gender or gender identity, but there’s a lot of nuance I’ve been missing.
I appreciate this thread. It’s been very informative.
Yes, me too. And there are lots of choices. You can transition to female, you can decide you are more comfortable as a non-gender-conforming man, you can continue to be a gender-conforming man in public. If you transition, that can be just social, just medical, or both. Medical transition had lots of pieces, and you can do some but not all. It’s helpful to have a therapist to navigate the help navigate the terrain.
To use Brian’s example (because he’s a close friend, and i happened to see him every week right after his therapy for a while), when he started his journey, he thought he had to do everything or nothing. And he was miserable doing nothing. But the idea of doing everything horrified him, in different ways. And he was really stressed by the choice. He’s found a path that works for him, and gives a lot of credit to his therapist.
Good! I swear to Og, gender essentialists just make me want to punch them. So many people are stuck in absolutely needless misery because of The Rules about what they’re supposed to wear, and like, and do, just because of what genitalia they were born with.
Hey folks, you know what you’re actually supposed to do if you have a penis? Urinate and ejaculate through it. (And clean under its foreskin if it has one.) That’s it. Basically all of the other prescribed “penis-haver behavior” is entirely optional.
No… I’m not undergoing a medical transition (which could result in a divorce).
A story… In 8th grade I was in a drama class. My teacher pulled me aside and said she had a part for me (Maynard) and gave me veto power. It was a boy vs. girl thing. Except me, I was a boy who hung out with the girls. The girls had dolls and I had a teddy bear. It was sort of making fun of me.
I’m not sure why she picked me for the part, but that basically describes me. Male, who hangs out with the girls, with a teddy bear, and not a doll. So, I like rom-coms but not the Hallmark channel. Want a touch of feminine stuff but only a touch. And all my friends are female. The only drawback is that Maynard got the laughs. And Maynard wouldn’t go over well in a small city in the Southern US. So, Lisa has to be under wraps.
Does your wife know about Lisa?
And AMAB folks get this pressure especially hard to do only manly things, I feel like women have more freedom as regards gender expression. We’re not supposed to go overboard with it but it’s not as big of a deal if we like man things. I’m a cisgender woman who wears makeup and presents pretty feminine but I always hung out with boys as a kid. I wonder if this was due to some social deficit I had - male social expectations were much easier for me to navigate than females’. I was always way more comfortable with guys because (generalizing) they are so much more direct. I was also much more physical, liked to wrestle and roughhouse, sometimes even went too far with the guys. Nobody ever told me, “you can’t be that way.” Of course my mother was a mechanical engineer so she made it her mission to free me of any gender constraints.
The biggest wall I consistently came up against was the idea that I was too smart for a girl. The other intelligent girls around me actively tried to hide their intelligence and I wouldn’t do it. I think a lot of guys were turned off by that.
But anyway, I can’t imagine living in a box as narrow as the one males often have to live in. It has to be stifling whether you’re trans or not. As a woman I can read whatever the hell I want to read, watch any kind of movie, wear pants, fix broken stuff, even shorten my name to something more masculine and nobody’s going to give me shit about it.
Time to trot out the Genderbread Person:
Lisa appears to want to express themselves in a feminine manner, but was AMAB (the “sex” aspect of the diagram). The matter of identity and attraction is for Lisa to work out.
But even that doesn’t have to be prescriptive. People are complicated and complex. You are allowed to be complicated and complex. Fuck (or rather don’t) the people who insist you must fit entirely into one box. You can choose a little from column A and a little from column B if that’s who you really are.
Incidentally I grew up being treated as “one of the girls” in my school circle, but I’m pretty sure most of them just assumed I was gay (I’m not, but I understand why I pinged their gaydar). I also carry a Lulu Guinness tote bag around town - basically an older version of this:
I don’t do it to feel feminine; I do it because I like the bag (and because LG totes are sturdy af) and also because I don’t care if people think I’m weird. I have embraced the weird and it is good. Figure out who you are, and embrace it.
TL;DR: You do you. Fuck the haters.
Ditto. Thanks.
Hear, hear!
First, I don’t want this thread to be about me. I was giving background behind why I asked what I did,
The answer is somewhat. Not the name Lisa. I hang out with her and her friends. I don’t have male friends (not counting co-workers) and she knows that, We watch Desperate Housewives, chick flicks, etc together. I never suggest male oriented movies/TV shows. She bought “comfortable dresses” for me to wear while working from home. Last week I noticed that the sweat pants she bought me were Bobbie Brooks. And she made a comment that she bought them in pink on purpose. So, I am Lisa-ish at home.
Sounds good! Would you consider it “cheating” in some way to be called Lisa in online groups like this, if your wife didn’t know? (No clue whether being called Lisa in online virtual conversations with all us possible chatbots would even be gratifying to you, and we don’t use our names much in dialogue on the Dope anyway bc everybody can see them on our posts.)
However, I second your concerns about going O/T from the OP’s chosen thread topic, and apologize to @Mollie_Magill if this is becoming too much of a hijack.
This.
I’m also learning lots. @Mollie_Magill Thanks for starting this thread.
We used this in years’ past in our Prevention Education programs (discussing gender-based violence.) Our PE team has always had a lot of trans people in it, I assume by word of mouth they hear our agency is a safe place to be out and also trans people are probably more interested in the nuances of gender in general.
I’m not sure if we still use the genderbread man. The current administration has issued executive orders to criminally prosecute nonprofits and individual staff who promote “gender ideology.” That’s almost certainly not legally enforceable but it has had a chilling effect on what’s been presented in these education programs.
It makes me sad a lot fewer students are getting this needed education.
Allow me to add my voice to the chorus of thanks for starting this thread. It has been very informative!
Is there another source for this? I can’t see anything.
Here’s a [Genderbread Person link.]
ETA: see below for less gross link
That is a super anti-trans website just FYI.
Oh yikes, sorry!! It was the same image as in @Gyrate’s post, and I didn’t look carefully at the site. Here’s a link to the site of the image’s creator instead.
Wow!
Mama Bear Apologetics teaches a traditional, biblical worldview on transgender identity, arguing that biological sex is fixed by God at birth and that cultural concepts of “gender identity” separate from biology conflict with Christian truth.
What in the world do they think that diagram means? (I’m not wading through their “ministry” to try to figure it out)
I am non-binary, I don’t take estrogen (my partner is nb and does take estrogen). As an example of dysphoria, facial hair and body hair made me feel like a mutant freak. I didn’t like how it looked or felt. It felt like turning into a werewolf (except I think it would be fun to be a werewolf). I was also convinced that nobody would find me attractive, for a variety of reasons.