So let's hold off on stabbing our neighbors in vigilante justice for just a moment...

I will not post when hopped up on caffeine.
I will not post when hopped up on caffeine.
I will not post when hopped up on caffeine.
I will not post when hopped up on caffeine.
I will not post when hopped up on caffeine. :eek:

Just think; I tried to write an essay too! But at least no one else saw that…

What I must have meant to say was; acting before you think it through. :smack:

How embarrassing…

This problem is why we have a judicial system, rules of evidence, lawyers, and so on, instead of allowing the victim or the victim’s family to go after someone who has committed a crime.

Here’s today’s episode: Sailor Kills Marine After Lie About Rape

Apparently a not particularly swift Petty Officer fancied himself in love with a hotel clerk calling herself Samantha (actually Ashley Elrod, 22). Young Miss Samantha/Ashley apparently told our hero that she had been gang raped by a number of service members, including a Marine named Huff or Huffman. When the sailor found a Marine named Huff, he posed as a Naval investigator, took the Marine for supposed questioning, slit his throat and buired his body.

Later it turns out that her name was not the only thing the young woman was lying about – she had made up the rape.

Ooops.

I thought that too, but not after reading the story KSO links to. The wife has to be in her late 20s to early 30s, while the victim was 59 years old and living with his parents–hardly gigolo material.

But this info on the victim being seen hanging around in his room naked by the killer is interesting. My guess? The killer already thought the victim was weird and disgusting, and hearing about possible molestation was just enough to push him over the edge. Sometimes people develop intense, irrational hatred of those who are different from them.

However, there’s never any telling why one person gets hooked up with another. It could’ve been due to her husband’s jealousy (or lack there of), it was easy, she was a nympho/lonely/emotionally or mentally disturbed, or any other of a million different reasons (or combinations). I’m sure we couldn’t guess either way.

That part sounds most plausible to me, added with the after-the-fact ‘addition’ of assumptions. Something wasn’t right in this mess, besides the murder. Wonder if it was possible that was the excuse given to cover up any molestation in the home?

More details here

Guy apparently had a big anger management problem

and wife pushed the right buttons

Sounds like the kid has been listening to too much bad '70s folk rock. Maybe her dad should have killed Dan Fogelberg.

My first thought on reading what the child supposedly said was, does any two-year-old actually speak like that? “He comes to me in the starry night” – does that sound like how a toddler would phrase something?

With such a serious story, I am so going to hell for laughing out loud at this! :smiley:

Gack! That’s Tom McClean-not Fogelberg…

I agree that there is much more to this story. And how close together are these houses that they can see the now deceased walking around naked? And why are they looking in other people’s windows?

And how do you explain this to this 2 year old daughter–Daddy’s in jail because he killed a man to protect you. Turns out you weren’t in danger? Sooner or later, the kid/teen/young woman will figure this out.
This guy needs the book thrown at him-he needs to be tried for murder and sent to prison, attempts at pulling heart strings should not be admitted into court.

:: cough ::

That would be Don McLean

And then have it discovered that the attorney had never stabbed their loved one to death in the first place? How embarassing would that be?

Enjoy,
Steven

:eek:

Most self-respecting zombies at least wear torn clothes covering their nether regions.

Dunno about there, but here in Denver the trend has been to build huge houses on small lots. In many developments, one could almost reach out the window and touch the house next door.

Actually, that sounds like a really good plot for my NaNoWriMo novel if you don’t mind my borrowing it?

That’s why you wait until AFTER the trial to exact vigilante justice.

Been done - in fact, the very first Alfred Hitchcock Presents had exactly this plot. (The first episode of the remake series did too.) A man and his wife, who has gone through a trauma, move into a trailer park. When he comes back from work one day, he finds she has been raped. Enraged, he asks her to point out the guilty party. They drive around, and then she points to a man on the street and says “he did it!” The husband murders him in revenge. Then

his revenge achieved, they are driving around again, when she points to another man walking on the street and cries "he did it! That’s the one.

The end.

where I grew up some 50 years ago, there was very little space between houses.

Here is a big part of the problem. This in NO way excuses what the father did, but after seeing what our poor excuse for a justice system often does in these cases, one can see where people would feel (wrongly of course, but it’s understandable) the need to take justice into their own hands.

Too often the animals that are actually guilty of this, get a stern lecture, perhaps a few months in jail and then get put on a list, Great big whoop, this hardly helps the parents know which are the dangerous ones, as anyone who ever got caught peeing in a park can get slapped on the sex offenders registry (sarcasm, peeing probably isn’t a sex offender offense, but I’ve heard of some pretty mild ones that had nothing to do with minors).

So while I don’t agree with the man’s actions, the courts (and their inaction regarding punishing sex offenders) own a big part in having created the atmosphere in which people think this is their only option.