Alan Smithee: A man starts out from home. He goes a little ways and turns left. Then he goes a little ways and turns left again. He goes a little ways and turns left yet again. As he comes home, two men with masks are waiting for him. Who are these people?
I’m not sure if I wrote it out right, but that’s the general idea.
A man walks into a bar (ouch!) and asks the bartender for a glass of water. The bartender pulls out a shotgun. The man thanks the bartender and leaves. What happened?
I always heard it as “The man was afraid to go home because the man in the mask was there. Who was the man in the mask?” Much less solvable than in your version.
Belated thanks to all who provided the posthumous set-ups to my answers. I couldn’t have done better myself.
Re: the albatross: Chronos nailed it, but to clarify: When he tasted the albatross AT THE RESTAURANT it was quite different from the albatross he ate on the island after the shipwreck (in which his wife died). He put 2 and 2 together and realized what had happened.