"Some Discomfort" or Why can't doctors tell the truth about pain?

An interesting point on the doc being “emotionally distanced.” All in all, I think I prefer a doctor to be as emotionally distanced as possible. My own thought is that this keeps him objective. My wife’s last oncologist actually wept at his inability to help her despite his trying everything recommended and some ideas of his own. Making unexpected house calls, pulling strings inside the hospital, and generally trying everything in his power. He didn’t do it in front of her but it had a fairly horrible effect on me. I started giving up about that time. In fairness, I have to say that he and his wife were close friends of us both but in retrospect I think that might not have been best for any of us. (Just part of being in Saudi. Good medical care is very much a matter of checking into doctors before you visit them.)

On a different topic, is there no way to objectively measure pain? After all, my “5” might be your “3”, or “8”. Surely there is some method of measuring pain receptor stimulation. I was thinking of some kind of EEG-type device but maybe these are insufficiently selective. Just curious.

Regards

Testy

As far as I know, there is no objective way to measure pain–because it is so linked to the individual, their perception of it, their cultural behaviors to it, plus the whole peripheral vs central nervous system stimulation.

The best we can get is an estimate. It doesn’t help much when we have essentially uneducated pts who have no words for their pain other than it “hurts”. I doubt that this would be the response if Dopers were asked, unfortunately, it often IS the response when I ask my pts.

Osler -very well said, and that post also applies to nurses as well.