Thanks for the recommendation; it’s the first one that I’ve not bought on sight - it seemed more expensive than most cds, and the previous couple were fine but not great… I guess I’ll go shopping!
And Rubberbandman is good - I’ve got the cd single with the 5" wide rubberband (with a 3-d face pressed into it) round the case 
Damn, I’ve got the 5" single also but no rubberband or 3-d face.
“Should Iiiiii, Know Whyiiiiiii, I’m in luv with you”
I’ve found “The Eye” on e-bay a couple times for around $7 but always got outbid at the last minute.
I’ve got all 4 different 5" singles of HOW HOW and some kind of orange and transparent cd with a loop of Oh Yeah in a clear circular case. And the 5" single of Jingle Bells!
“Oh Yeah” also showed up in The Secret of My Success, IIRC.
You’re probably thinking of “Jane’s Getting Serious”, by Jon Astley.
This site, http://www.thefirstcut.net/yelrub2.htm, has a picture; the eyes are out of sight on the back… the face is too big for it all to fit on one side.
I’m in the UK; the shop price here for The Eye seems to be about £18 or so…
You’re still here?
It’s over go home.
Go on, go.