Okay, personally, I think the third one was great. The more I watch it, the better it gets. And I’ve read a bunch of the scripts that weren’t used, and if Gibson’s is the one that focused on Hicks, and you thought that was better than what was put out there, then you really need to re-read that script, because it sucked 1,000,000 times worse than the monk script, which was essentially what they made, only worse. At least that one had some interesting ideas…the Gibson one was utter, utter shit. but we’ll get into that later.
Alien: Ressurrection was also shit, and really did suck, but it is kinda fun at some points. I liked the crew of the Betty, especially Ron Pearlman’s character. It did have a good look to it at points, and the escape scene was awesome, but the whole hybrid thing blew. The theory was that the blood sample they had was from the prison planet from three, and that Riply’s being host to the thing tainted her blood enough that there was some incombant alien DNA in it (kinda like how you can tell a woman’s pregnant by a blood test, I guess; the embryo takes on some genetic traits of the host, and seemingly changes the host a bit, maybe to help others of the species know a host is a host and not dinner). Anyway, there were problems separating the two, hence Ripleys 1-7, Ripley 8’s little quirks (blood, finger claws, animal instincts, strength, reflexes, etc), and a few other character traits in the aliens themselves which were never really touched on aside from the “human reproductive system” piece of shit.
I know a lot of people that like this movie because it’s a return to the whole “dark mother” psychology of the first two. I liked three because it got more to the horror of the creature itself. As much as I love Aliens, it gets boring the more I watch it, whereas the first and third ones just get better with each viewing. I prefer the horror over the action…means the characters have to be more inventive.
My biggest little pet peeve with Ressurrection is that it takes place on a military space station, and at the first sign that the twelve little critters on board get loose, all the heavily armed military personel evacuate. Wha???
I did like the bit where the infected guy beat the crap out of evil heartless scientist guy, and held him up just right so that when the chest burster blew out of his chest, it went straight threw the other guy’s head. That was a rather cool sequence.
But yeah, an adaptation of Aliens: Bood One, Two and Earth Wars would have been much cooler. I just wish they’d finally put Ripley to rest and do something more original with the storyline.