Starship development and progress [previous title: Will Musk's starship reach orbit this year?]

Trying to reassure when you know the odds are only e.g. 50-50 has at least as much opportunity to dissuade investors as persuade them. So that seems a dumb move they’d be unlikely to make.

We’ll see what happens. As I’ve noted before, our old friend @Stranger_On_A_Train used to maintain that space mission success statistics are basically meaningless until you have a couple hundred launches under your belt. Prior to that number you simply haven’t had a chance to explore the envelope well enough to know whether your shit always works or you’ve just been lucky.

Starship is simply a long way short of anyone making statistically backed confident noises. In either direction. Your question is unanswerable. Their management is acting confident. And there has to be a first full recovery attempt someday.

We shall see. I wish them well.

Booster got dunked.

Oops.

They aborted it to practically on the beach. I wonder how many animals got cooked?

So now we see tomorrow if the orbiter gets recovered. Even if it never flies again that would still be a milestone.

Eh. The ocean is full of animals. We privilege the ones on land, but that’s mere speciesism.

I was looking at all those birds at the bottom of the photo.

I didn’t notice them until you pointed them out.

But yeah, you’re right; they’re fucked.

Probably none. They would have heard it coming down toward them and scattered. The picture is likely birds in the foreground.

They are saying that the booster was running too low on fuel for the catch attempt.

About an hour away from trying for the orbiter.

Daniel caught the fly.

Absolutely amazing. Congratulations to the Starship team. It was so smooth that it somehow made it look less impressive, like they’ve done this 1000 times. The heat shield looks great as well. Comparing it to the condition during the 1st atmospheric re-entry you can tell they probably have it mostly solved.

here is the catch:

Yes! Yes! Yes! The Starship program desperately needed this.

Is this the first time the Ship itself has been caught?

I’m also interested to know just how reusable it actually turns out to be.

Yes. Early bloc tests had what’s now the upper stage launch a few miles up and then land again. Those tests tended to be “engine rich” and led to completely replacing the v1 engines with v2 and now v3.

Even if this particular ship is never reused, I think that the splashdown recovered Starships must have been in good enough shape for SpaceX to decide it was time to start making return to base a thing.

I think that Starship has now passed the goalpost of being at least potentially refurbishable if not yet truly reusable.