Stupid bloody Yakima rack. Grr.

(Not sure where this is supposed to go. It’s part grumpy kvetching but without enough bad words to make it go in the pit and part desperate plea for help with a recalcitrant piece of automotive/bicycle equipment.)

As I’ve mentioned elsewhere, I’ve returned to the midwest from Manhattan. One of the things I looked forward to, coming back, was riding my bike again. A lovely Long Haul Trucker, suitable for riding cross-country if I’m so inclined; also perfectly adequate for toodling around the Columbus metropolitan area.

One problem: It’s currently in the basement of my parents’ house, down in Cincinnati. What I need is a BICYCLE RACK to put on my car! Also, it’d be nice to be able to drive it out to remote locations, and I do have dreams of mountain biking again. So I sensibly go to the Local Bicycle Retailer and buy the various bits and pieces of a roof-rack for my 'speed 3–Q-towers (designed by Q, for maximum frustration, I think), Q-clips (see towers), big long poles, thingies to put the actual bikes on. The salesguy asks if I’ve ever installed one of these before. This should’ve been a SCREAMING ALARM and FLASHING RED LIGHT, as he indicated it was somewhat difficult. (He suggested a six pack and an afternoon. A keg and a fifth or two of whiskey would’ve been more like it. Maybe.) But no, no, I’m confident in my abilities. I buy, I come back and pick up, I take home and clutter up my apartment with.

And then I finally decide to start putting together. Here the [del]fun[/del]frustration begins. There are four measurements that are of critical importance to the whole thing. The first one that I meet is the distance from one tower to the other. You have to set this within 1/8" of the value you look up for your car. Fair enough, no problem. Then you have to center the bar on the towers. Except that every time I try to move the bar, the towers shift and my measurement goes off. Cursing and sweating ensue. In about an hour and a half, I finally get the thing right! But there’s no way I’m going to take this out to try and put it on the car today, so it clutters up my apartment for a while longer.

A few weeks later, it’s a nice day, so I take the thing out to the car. This is where I learn that the first bit was actually quite easy. See, here the object is to achieve 'BALANCED TOWER TENSION. Yakima loves that phrase, BALANCED TOWER TENSION. I plop the rack on top of the car, get it more or less centered and the proper number of inches away from the windshield, and start to work on achieving BALANCED TOWER TENSION. The way you’re supposed to do this is open up the cam on one side, turn a tightening bolt one turn, close the cam (and put the system under unbalanced tower tension), then go around to the other side of the car, do the same thing, repeat until you have achieved BALANCED TOWER TENSION. There’s only one problem with this plan: Every time I close a cam cover, it moves the whole thing off-center. So I wind up with lots of TOWER TENSION on one side, and very little on the other. Not, I fear, what anyone would consider BALANCED. Rending of hair and gnashing of teeth ensue, with some incidental wailing. Not to be deterred, I take the thing to a local bike shop (not where I got it, which is down in Cincinnati). The local bike shop guy is as stymied by the damned thing as I am.

So now I’ve got a very expensive garage-clutterer (I’ve moved it out of the apartment) that is of absolutely no use to me because I lack the almost mystical skills (and patience, I suspect) to put it on. I’ve been trying to figure out what to do. I was thinking about posting on craigslist (Come put this rack on for me! $100 and beer!), but they don’t seem to have a category for this sort of thing. Alternatively, I can put it on craigslist (buy this thing from me! no guarantees on whether you will ever be able to affix it to a car!). I’ve been thinking of trying to take it back to the original bike shop and begging them to take it away from me and give me my money back and then taking that money to either the dealer (I think Mazda offers a rack as an accessory) or the local bike shop to get some stuff that they’re actually familiar with and able to help me install, if necessary.*

So, for the experienced, any advice, or should I just go invest in some sackcloth and ashes to go with the rent-hair/gnashed-teeth look?

*An aside here: I’ve noticed in looking at the roof of my car that it has these little thingies that look remarkably like slide off covers at about where you might expect a rack to mount. And apparently there are things called “fixpoints” and racks that take advantage of them. Racks that sound much more joy inducing than the one I have. Racks that do not demand you achieve BALANCED TOWER TENSION. I think I might need one of these racks.

I’m originally from across the Ohio River in Covington and Erlanger.

I don’t like roof racks for the 4 obvious reasons.

  1. Running the bikes into garage door and other low hanging items.
  2. Dirt, rain, and bugs hitting the bike at high speeds.
  3. Difficulty lifting the bike up there.
  4. Reduced gas mileage even when the bike isn’t up there. (Sometimes wind noise too).

Speaking of #1, a buddy ran his bike into his garage 3 times before going to a trunk rack. Then he lowered the garage door on it. :smack:

Trunk bike racks are also a pain to install and can make opening a trunk difficult.

That’s why I like trailer hitch bike racks.

  1. Don’t have to worry about hitting low objects, but getting rear-ended can be a worry.
  2. The bike stays cleaner especially if it’s behind a mini-van, SUV, or station wagon.
  3. Very easy to install the bike. Plus removing the rack is very easy and some racks make an excellent workstand.
  4. With the rack off, gas mileage isn’t reduced. If you leave the rack on, just a tiny drop. Even with the bike on the rack, it’s not much of a problem with a mini-van, SUV, or station wagon. It can be an issue with a sedan where the bike is popped up sideways into the air stream.

Of course a trailer hitch cost extra money to install.

OH! With either a hitch rack or trunk rack make really sure that the car’s exhaust isn’t pointed at the bike tires. It can melt the tires and weaken the rims and spokes.

Also go +1 on the capacity. If you plan on carrying 2 bikes, get a 3 bike rack. Trust me on this.

I feel your pain. When I first attempted achieving balanced tower tension I had such a hard time and got so frustrated I gave up…I was so mad I didn’t even take my bike on that trip. Eventually I was able to get the damn thing mounted on my car, but not without a lot of sweat and cursing. I’m afraid I can’t offer any advice other than not drinking beer – that just makes it harder I think.

I will say that a properly mounted Yakima rack is a very solid and dependable way to transport your bike…once you get it on. Travel tip: make sure you know how much clearance you need…replacing your forks (a likely casualty when smashing into a low ceiling…I know from experience) is pretty expensive.

Just tell your hoodlum friends outside you ain’t got time to take a ride.
Yakima rack! Don’t talk back.

Can’t you just pay some local bike shop wrench monkey to put it on?

Yeah, that doesn’t sound like a good way to spend the day, even following Yakima’s “easy” how-to video. If you don’t have a friend to tighten the other cam at the same time until both close pretty firmly, would temporarily duct taping both sides into position to avoid slipping help (just a piece or two over the top of the bar)?

I have a Yakima rack that screws into the fix points you mentioned. It’s been trouble free for five years. I’m glad I sprung for the windscreen if you go that route. It really cuts down on wind noise.

Good luck.

Count yourself lucky.

For Thule kayak racks on a Congo Cage it took me a couple of days, a sledge hammer, a grinder with a cutting wheel, a drill press, a mitre saw and a router.

Get a buddy to help you so that each of you can work on different sides of the car at the same time. Loosen everything off enough that you can find where the mounts fits best relative to the shape of the sides of the roof of your car, then tighten up the cross-bar. Then try the cams repeatedly, starting so that they are both too loose even with both cams engaged, and then tightening them only a wee little bit each time until you find the right balance. Think of it as Yakima foreplay.

(When including the rack lift setup, it also took a come-along/winch, a dozen feet of webbing, and a four foot long two inch square section of aluminium tubing. When including the roof retraction, it also took a few feet of fibreglass tent pole. And then there’s the canoe mount and kayak racks on the trailer . . . .)

A quick googling seems to indicate that those actually are slide off covers and that apparently all late model Mazda 3’s have the holes drilled for a factory roof rack. That’s not always the case-- sometimes the fixpoints only cover the spot where the holes would go had the buyer sprung for the roof rack.

So with that in mind, if you can get your money back for the IQ test roof rack, a factory rack might be the best solution. It’s almost certainly the best solution aesthetically. It looks like it should pretty much bolt on and you can get one off Amazon for $350ish bucks. You might even be able to find one cheaper at a salvage yard, although your car may be a little too new for that yet. If you do go that route, you may want to check with a Mazda enthusiast forum to confirm the above.

Update: The store was very cool about it, and is happy to exchange for a rack that uses the fixpoints. Now all I need to do is figure out how to get the covers off…

Geez, I live in Wenatchee, WA, just north of Yakima. I thought this was going to have to do with Yakima, the town. But reading the OP reminded me of the Yakima brand or bike racks.

My own trunk-mounted bike rack isn’t a Yakima, but my god it’s a pain.

I think they named the town in Washington after the brand of bike racks.

Anyway, further update: Today I successfully bolted a bike rack to my car, and used it to transport my bike 100ish miles up the interstate without incident (other than it making terrifying noises when I was parked in a gas station lot… :dubious:). I’m a very happy monkey today.

Likewise, Tacoma, WA and that Toyota truck… :stuck_out_tongue: