Hi there. Well, this is a summary of a letter I actually sent to the RIAA, to which they have not responded after 3 months. I actually sent it twice, and received no reply. Curious behavior for an organization that says music piracy is a “plain and simple issue” and that they have “nothing to hide”…but maybe they get a lot of these sorts of letters and are swamped.
So, what I would like to know is if these simple-sounding questions have a simple answer, with cites to support the answers that anyone is kind enough to supply. The reason I ask for cites is that this issue apparantly gathers much mis-information and “guesstimates” of what the law really is. What I am searching for is the Last Word on some simple questions about music copyright. It would be nice to have a thread which is the “last word” on some of these issues, so the thrice-daily Napster thread could be pointed towards this.
It would also be nice to only try to answer these as questions of fact, not a debate over Napster or the issue of copyright per se.
Well, here they are:
-
I own a CD of an album or song. Can I download a song from that album if the CD is in my car downstairs, or in the other room, and like the Comic Store guy on The Simpsons I have been defeated by the Evil Captain Leather Computer Chair?
-
I own an LP/45/8-track of an album or song. However, I have no LP/45/8-track player to play the album or song with. Can I legally download the album via Napster?
-
I purchase a CD legitimately, and then believe it is lost. Can I download the songs via Napster rather than find it?
-
I purchase a CD legitimately, and then know without a doubt it is lost, stolen, or destroyed. Can I download the songs via Napster rather purchase a new one?
-
I own an LP/45/8-track of a specific song - say “Canned Heat” by Jamiroquai (3:17 minutes). However, there are also two longer, extended dance versions of the same song (5:30 and 3:46 minutes). Assuming I can download the song (question 1) since I have a copy on CD, can I also download the “alternate” versions of it? (on this one, I’m guessing ‘no’, but have to see if others know)
-
I loan a CD to a friend. While the friend has the CD, I want to hear a song from it. The friend is not listening to the CD, as she left it at work and cannot get it to me. She has no intention of listening to it again, but it is in her possession. Assuming the answer to question 1 was yes, can I download the song?
-
(True story, happened in Lawrence, KS when I was in college) A local band plays at a block party, and tells everyone that it is illegal to record them in any way, shape, or form. This is in a public street. People on the corner bring out a tape recorder and record the music from their property. Have they broken the law?
-
Although few do this anymore, can I burn a CD of songs I record from the radio, for my personal use?
-
Yes, this one does confuse me. Do I have the right to make one backup copy for my personal, archival use, of CD music media?
and finally, because Una’s Rule says a list this long must reach 10,
- Hi Fierra!
So…anyone up to the challenge?