The 452-millionth "help me remember a movie" thread

It was probably a rom-com of some kind. Set in modern times (i.e., not a period piece). In an American city. The hero was not a sophisticated guy but a gentle, shy sort of fellow (I think).

The only scene I remember is that he is trying to impress the woman and he sets up a “date” scenario on the roof of his apartment building (a pretty modest apartment-- I think). Maybe because he’s too broke to take her to a nice restaurant (I think). It’s nighttime, there’s a little table and rickety chairs, and he has made some food, maybe Italian food? She is impressed. He has a radio playing and they start to slow dance. Wish I could remember the song-- that might help. Then it starts to rain gently and they keep dancing in the rain. It may sound corny but it comes across as quite sweet and romantic.

Sound familiar to anyone?

You’re sure this wasn’t an episode of Frasier? :face_with_raised_eyebrow:

Hmmm…I really don’t think so… My admittedly vague memory of the guy is that he’s modest and not too sure of himself. That’s not exactly Frasier.

I suppose this might have happened when Niles was wooing Daphne. Geez, if that’s the case I’m going to be really disappointed. I was looking forward to seeing the movie again when some sharp Doper named it for me.

There were two “rooftop” episodes. One had slow dancing, the other had a meteor shower.

Didn’t something like that happen in The Room? There was some shenanigans on the roof.

But surely you would remembered that train wreck.

Could it be “The Goodbye Girl”?

At the end of this scene, it starts to rain.

That scene from The Goodbye Girl might be it…

It’s one of my favorite movies. Written by Neil Simon. It is a very 70s sweet and romantic film. Richard Dreyfuss won the best actor Oscar for his role.

Is it possible it was How I Met Your Mother? They had at least one rooftop scene with rain but they were not dancing during it.

Now that we’ve considered variations of the theme, does anyone have any idea when it was first done? :thinking: