The Bad Seed, Different Ending?

I know that this has been discussed before on the Dope, but it’s been a while.

Yesterday, I finally watched my recording of TCM’s Halloween presentation of the movie, The Bad Seed. I’ve watched it many times before. I know the infamous ending was a bow to the Hays Code which would not allow criminals to get away with their crimes. The result was the most blatant Deus ex Machina in film history.

Of course, in the original play, Rhoda survives her mother’s attempt to poison her, and her mother dies by suicide, which is how the 1985 TV remake ended. The remake was okay as TV movies go, but not as memorable as the 50’s film.

Now, if you had been in charge of the 50’s production of the movie, how would you have placated the censors? I think I would’ve let both Rhoda and her mother, Christine, die. Then a final scene would’ve had a devastated Kenneth Penmark, Rhoda’s father, tearing into the deceased Christine for the murder/suicide to an equally bereft Richard Bravo, Christine’s adoptive father. Richard could remain painfully stoic with the secret knowledge of who’s guilty, and observe that there is no understanding evil. Or something like that.

Would that have been a better ending? Or should the lightning bolt stay?

I understand the intent of your ending, but I’m not sure it would have placated the censors.

Additionally, does Christine die in the movie? I haven’t seen the movie in years, but I have thing vague memory that Christine survives-- or at least that her survival was somehow up in the air at the end of the movie.

[necessary spoiler]

I have seen the play, and owned a copy of the text of it, and yes, they both die in the stage play. IIRC, someone “novelized” the play, and they both die there, too.

Wait, in the original they both die? Then what’s with that Zeus based ending?

No, in the movie, Christine survives, because she has one of those saintly 50’s film doctors.

[SPOILER] [SPOILER] [SPOILER] [SPOILER] [SPOILER] [SPOILER]:

I can’t find my copy of it, so it must be in the storage shed (ie, not in the building, in the remote locker), but I’m thinking that in the original, Christine gave Rhoda the sleeping pills, then shot herself with a handgun. We hear the gun go off remotely-- that is, we see Christine take the gun, in the visible set (the living room, it would be, in a typical staging of the play), then she walks into another “room,” which is to say, she exits through a door built into the living room set, and we hear the gun go off.

I can’t remember whether that is the very last scene, or if there is a scene with the other characters that makes it clear that both Rhoda and Christine are, in fact, dead. I think in the novelization, it is made absolutely clear, but I don’t know whether the intent of the playwright is to make it slightly ambiguous whether Rhoda actually died of the sleeping pills, or just not to show us anyone’s grief, as at that point it would be gratuitous-- after all, he wrote such a wrenching scene with Claude’s mother, I can’t imagine what he write for Rhoda’s father.

I have seen the movie three or four times, most recently about two or three years ago. I saw the play only once, though. It was a university production, and very good-- high production values, and seniors and grad students in acting at a pretty decent state school, which has turned out some very good performers. Not Yale drama, but not a community theater production either. Anyway, it was either when I was a student, or shortly thereafter, so it was about 30 years ago.

I read the novelization when I was around 30, so maybe 24 years ago.

I do have a pretty good memory for such things, but I also sometimes conflate things when they were that long ago. It’s also not impossible that different endings for the play exist: if the playwright wanted to end it with both dead, and the producer wanted both to live, they could have compromised with only Christine living, but may have written all three endings, and the distribution company offered all three endings to producers and directors who wanted to rent the script-- or get permission to put on an amateur production for free, like a high school production-- so actually, all those endings may be out there.

I’m not saying they are, just that I know from doing theater in high school that when you book a script, sometimes you are offered multiple endings, or scenes that are either alternate version of scenes, or additional scenes that can be included or left out.