The best QB ever poll

Over in the Game Room there’s a good thread about who is the best quarterback ever and it seems to me that that would make an interesting poll question. So here it is, and vote for no more than five (5). If you think of any I’ve missed, vote for “Other” and name him/them.

Moved IMHO --> Game Room.

Graham
Montana
Brady
Starr
Unitas

No Bret Favre? No Unitas?

How cool. My first post becomes a poll.

Srsly. Get a mod to close this thread and try again.

Joe Montana tops my list. Glad to see I’m in good company.

My next three are Fouts, Brees, and although it pains me to vote for him because I HATE the fucking Patriots, Tom Brady.

Mods, the criticism is on the money. Please close this thread and I’ll try it again with Favre and Johnny U.

Yeah, had to go with “other” and say Johnny Unitas.

In order
Graham
Baugh
Montana
“Other” Unitas
Brady

My “other” vote was for Favre.

Joe Montana. There can be only one.

Favre’s not even the best QB that played for the packers in the last 6 years.

Look at his numbers. His numbers and how many games he started are enough to put him in the top-10.

And Brees? Doesn’t belong in the top 20. Archie Manning and Jim Mcmahon but no Unitas or Favre?

What a joke.

Where is Drew Bledsoe? Randall Cunningham? Bernie Kosar? Elvis Grbac? Jeff Hostetler? Bobby Hebert?

I voted for:

Otto Graham
Joe Montana
Bart Starr
Tom Brady
Peyton Manning

Dan Majkowski? Randy White? Lynn Dickey?

I assume you mean Randy Wright, not Randy White. :slight_smile:

Although, I bet that White would have still been a better QB than Wright.

What is a pole, after all, but a growed up post?

Some odd omissions and odd inclusions, for sure.

I voted only for Otto and Joe.