As far as local lobster resturants in the York/Kittery/Eliot area go…
Bosn’s Landing off of Rte 1 in York;
decent lobster, really good OVESTUFFED lobster roll (think lobster in a hamburger roll filled so thick you have to dislocate your jaw to eat it), pricey though ($12 last I checked)
The Weathervane in Kittery;
decent lobster and lobster rolls, fairly priced, lobster rolls are on the traditional grilled hot dog roll with a bed of lettuce under the lobster (a couple leaves really)
Bob’s Clam Hut in Kittery;
directly across Rte 1 from The Weathervane, it’s an oversized roadside stand, Bobs and the Weathervane have sort of an impromptu competition between them, decent food, fair prices, their signature foods are the lobster roll (on a hot dog roll like the Weathervane) and their fried clams
of the three, you get the most lobster in Bosn’s, but they’re the most expensive, and all their prices are of the “rake in as much from the tourists as possible” variety, Bosn’s is the most expensive resturant of the three
if you want the most traditional New England experience of the three, go to Bob’s and eat your lobster roll on one of their picnic tables…
while you’re there, check out the Kittery Trading Post, on the same side of the road as Bob’s, it’s a HUGE sporting goods outfitter, you name it, they’ve probably got it, fishing tackle, archery, shooting sports, knives, clothing, camping supplies, kayaks, and canoes, tacky little gifts, across the street in the Tanger Outlet minimall, they have the KTP X-Sports division, which handles paintball, surfing, and bikes…