Was recently watching Reservoir Dogs. Mr. Pink flees the robbery, takes cover behind a car, and the camera dollies in as he fires over the hood, his entire face clenched. “That’s the shot that made Buscemi a star.”
There are quite a few of those: the shot that marked the turning point for an actor going from obscurity to being known, or character roles to stardom, or hey-it’s-that-guy to he’s-awesome.
M. Culkin slapping his face and screaming is the first that comes to mind. Julia Roberts shrieking with laughter and ducking her head in the bubble bath. Hugh Jackman prowling in the fight cage. Kate Winslet looking up from underneath the hat. (Yes, she was already known, but she wasn’t mainstream, IIRC.)
I might toss Anne Hathaway’s bit of physical comedy in falling off that chair in The Princess Diaries. That utterly endeared her to the audience, apparently forever (so far), and she’s run with it from there.
I gotta concur with Rilcham, Susan Sarandon was a star way before Atlantic City. Maybe her star turn was getting her freak on in Rocky Picture Horror Show.
Those are what I’m looking for. The other four actors were already known before the shots you mention. They’re signature images, to be sure, but not spark-to-the-fuse moments. For instance, I was going to include John Travolta strutting down the street, but then remembered he’d been known as Barbarino for several years by then.
Marlon Brando screaming “Stella!” in A Streetcar Named Desire
Judy Garland singing “Over the Rainbow” in The Wizard of Oz
Marlene Dietrich singing “Falling in Love Again” in The Blue Angel
Robert Redford’s card game at the beginning of Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
John Travolta carrying paint in Saturday Night Fever
Jack Nicholson getting stoned in Easy Rider
Vivian Leigh with suitors on the porch at Tara in Gone with the Wind
Brad Pitt in Thelma and Louise saying: “I like your wife.” with the smarmiest smirk ever. Until then I thought he was just some kind of 21 Jumpsreetesque pretty guy.