There’s a big animal rescue in my area whose strength is very much in sensationalizing and exaggerating every story and going for publicity over real good work. You know- the sort where every sweet pit bull they take is a “rescued bait dog” even if there’s zero evidence to suggest that they were ever anything other than a pet. It works for them, of course, even if it’s often really dishonest. Their thing today is a hoarder house complete with video of the house and a screed about how heartbreaking and disgusting it is.
Thing is, the people who surrender their animals to you are people too. Some of them, yes, are assholes and idiots who should never have had an animal in the first place. And some are people in a tough situation out of their control who are making a heartbreaking decision in order to keep their beloved best friend safe. And most of them are some combination of those.
Hoarders, though, are delicate. Hoarder house rescues come with large numbers of animals at once who often need a lot of vet care, which is costly. And if you want to, you can really play up the story and people will eat it up and donate. The squalor. The neglect. The cockroaches and soiled furniture. Oh, how could anyone? Oh, I hate people! Oh, what a monster!
But it’s counterproductive if what you want is to be able to rescue hoarded or neglected animals or prevent it from happening in the first place. Because most of these people aren’t monsters. They’re not perfect and hoarding animals is indisputably a bad thing and it doesn’t happen without some bad decisions and irresponsible pet ownership, but for the most part, they’re overwhelmed. It’s more a lack of money, education, resources, social support, and so forth. The hoarders themselves are generally living in the same conditions as the animals, which should tell you it’s not something they do out of malice.
Anyway, the thing is, they don’t always realize it’s too much until it’s too much, you know? Especially if they weren’t in a great place to begin with and couldn’t really afford the first animal. And at that point, especially if they’re on social media, they know that if they call for help and allow rescuers into their houses and allow other people to see what’s been going on, they may end up with photos of their home all over the internet with a caption about how the heroic rescuers saved all these beautiful innocent animals from the torture of living with such a disgusting evil slob. Along with the accompanying comments about how they’re scum and they make people sick and how they should rot in Hell and how people are in tears just looking at the pictures.
So. You can either walk a delicate line, trying to raise donations for the animals you brought in while still having some compassion for and respecting the dignity and privacy of the owner and any other potential owners who might be hesitant to ask for help or allow someone to ask for help on their behalf… or you can stoke the flames for your own benefit, which will get you some sweet, sweet money and publicity. And encourage those hoarders to keep on hoarding until they die or until the house gets condemned. It makes a better story that way.