I know I’m a minority of one here, but I think it was an incredible mistake for the White House to release that photo, much more so than OBL’s death photo would have been. Obama will always have Secret Service protection, of course, but if I were any other government functionary pictured in that room, I’d be pretty nervous especially if my job required me to travel internationally.
CNN has an entire article about the photo now. It repeatedly veers into overanalysis but it makes some interesting points. One is that if you didn’t already know Obama was president, you wouldn’t pick it up from the photo- on top of whatever assumptions you might make about what a U.S. president looks like or what his posture might look like, Obama is also not front and center in any particular way.
And for the historical record, Sec. Clinton says she was trying to cover up a cough. Like a lot of people I thought she looked horrified.
The other interesting thing about the photo is that you can see what a Rorschach test it is for people. I said in another post that Obama looked “grim,” and I’m sure my reading of his expression and Clinton’s say plenty much about my view of the killing.
It’s worth viewing the photo at full size, if your computer can handle it (big file): http://www.flickr.com/photos/whitehouse/5680724572/sizes/o/in/photostream/
At high resolution the “blurred” photo in front of Clinton is obviously pixelated, whatever it is. But what’s really striking is the emotion you can see on the faces that simply isn’t visible at smaller scales, where you can’t discern facial lines, tight jaw muscles and such. Obama and Clinton in particular look a hell of a lot more worried than they have since let on.
Its almost as if he has pulled up a chair, keeping quiet and just watching from the sidelines as the important guys around the table do their jobs. He is off to the side, sitting on a spare chair dragged in from the next room. No laptop for him, he is just a spectator at this point.
But to me this position doesnt say “shrinking violet”, more that he is self-confident enough, and secure enough in himself to step back and let his staff do their jobs. No posturing, he has made the calls now he is letting the rest of the team go to work. I would imagine his staff appreciate that.
It’s interesting that the obscured document is easier to make sense of in the medium and large versions of the photo vs. the “original” size. I’m guessing there is some sort of information theory thing about data compression and such going on there.
The obscured document is sitting on top of a non-obscured document, a picture of the compound that doesn’t look too different than what you can get from Google…so my guess it is a higher-resolution view of the compound, as I said upthread (unless, that’s what they want us to think! /cue dramatic music).
Everybody’s face is interesting, but Clinton and Obama, the two most famous people in the room, have the most memorable expressions as well. I know it’s his job, but while everybody else is focused on the front of the room, the photographer turned away from what was obviously so captivating. If I was the photographer, I would have been distracted by whatever it was the others were listening or watching and missed this historic moment.
Pete Souza is very good at capturing moments like those in this picture. If you haven’t run through the White House flickr photo streamlately, you should. Interesting to note that the 9 photos in the May photo set are well on their way to 800,000 views already, while April photos haven’t even made it to 200,000 and March photos are under 70,000.
Two interesting things I read in the Times. First, they canceled White House tours that day so that no tourists would run into top national security people going down the hall on Sunday. Two, a staffer made a CostCo run to get snacks and soda. They listed what he got, but I forget. Maybe they didn’t want the White House cooks to know?