I consider this definitive proof that the band name is The Beatles.
[QUOTE=Boyo Jim]
I consider this definitive proof that the band name is The Beatles.
[/QUOTE]
If you go by that, the band’s full name is Ludwig The Beatles.
[QUOTE=Biffy the Elephant Shrew]
If you go by that, the band’s full name is Ludwig The Beatles.
[/QUOTE]
The Ludwig is silent.
Data point:
I’m editing some documents that are on their way to the Executive Board of UNDP, so you can imagine how important funding partners’ names are (especially as these deal with what the organization has done with the funds). This very issue had popped up, and I sent the following email on June 6[sup]th[/sup] (bolding is in both email and their response):
Here is the reply I just received:
Sometimes it pays to be pedantic!
Now, can anyone help me remember some movie/television scene where a few kids are arguing over whether it’s Smokey Bear or Smokey the Bear? All I can (vaguely) remember is the line “but it’s not Super the Man!”.
Rhythm
[QUOTE=Boyo Jim]
The Ludwig is silent.
[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=Boyo Jim]
I consider this definitive proof that the band name is The Beatles.
[/QUOTE]
There’s really nothing definitive about that.
(1) The “the” is entirely in small caps, so it tells you nothing about proper capitalization
(2) It’s a logo. Proper capitalization is not dictated by logos. You don’t write “SONY” or “FORD” in all caps just because they appear in all caps on the logos appearing Sony and (some) Ford products.
(3) It’s a display. Proper capitalization is not dictated by displays.
(4) It’s a label. It’s shorthand for saying “The people you see playing up here are the Beatles.” It doesn’t say anything about a proper name, or whether there is any such thing as a “proper” name when it comes to an entity like a band.
[QUOTE=acsenray]
There’s really nothing definitive about that.
(1) The “the” is entirely in small caps, so it tells you nothing about proper capitalization
(2) It’s a logo. Proper capitalization is not dictated by logos. You don’t write “SONY” or “FORD” in all caps just because they appear in all caps on the logos appearing Sony and (some) Ford products.
(3) It’s a display. Proper capitalization is not dictated by displays.
(4) It’s a label. It’s shorthand for saying “The people you see playing up here are the Beatles.” It doesn’t say anything about a proper name, or whether there is any such thing as a “proper” name when it comes to an entity like a band.
[/QUOTE]
I was unclear in making my point. It was not about whether “The” should be capitalized, it was about the name of the group. They were The Beatles, not Beatles with a “the” stuck in front for grammatical purposes.
[QUOTE=Boyo Jim]
I was unclear in making my point. It was not about whether “The” should be capitalized, it was about the name of the group. They were The Beatles, not Beatles with a “the” stuck in front for grammatical purposes.
[/QUOTE]
Maybe I’m being dim but please help me understand why both of the following sentences are correct:
I own six Beatles albums.
I own three Weezer albums.
but to say it this way would require using “the” in one place and not the other:
I own six albums by the Beatles.
I own three albums by Weezer.
[QUOTE=Kolak of Twilo]
Maybe I’m being dim but please help me understand why both of the following sentences are correct:
I own six Beatles albums.
I own three Weezer albums…
[/QUOTE]
In the first sentence, you are using an abreviated form of their name.
In the second sentence, I don’t care. WTF cares about Weezer? 
[QUOTE=AuntiePam]
Even when “The” is part of the title? Like The Stand, The Wizard of Oz, The Godfather, etc. etc.?
[/QUOTE]
Or The Hague?
I’d like to visit The Gambia someday.
[QUOTE=Spectre of Pithecanthropus]
Or The Hague?
[/QUOTE]
Don’t be vague, it’s always been The Hague.
As for the Beatles, I agree with the OP. Lower-case that Shit. 
Colophon (newspaper copyeditor (when not on the Dope))
[QUOTE=Boyo Jim]
The Ludwig is silent.
[/QUOTE]
I doubt it, or The Ringo wouldn’t have had much use for it.
–wolfstu, chilling out in The Netherlands