Is anyone keeping score of what amendments are debated or ignored. What good is SCOTUS ruling on things like the Bill of Rights if the accused terrorist is already sleeping on a concrete floor in a Salvadorean Supermax with an aluminum blanket? Cruel and unusual punishment is in there somewhere (it was already in the Magna Carta) so I’ll have a go:
1st amendment really is so broad. Freedom is religion is mostly there, unless you are the wrong religion. Freedom of speech is dicey - best have a lawyer if you’re gonna speak freely. Assembly? Not really. At some point you’re a mob and the buses will pull up to cart you off for a night or three. Petition the government? Again, have an advocate or lawyer’s phone number.
2nd: Not broad enough, at least in intent. Some say it was meant to fight tyranny and some say it’s to shoot people who tread on your property.
3rd? If soldiers are inclined to “quarter in private homes” - how many guns have you (as per 2nd) to prevent them?
4th (unreasonable searches) and 5th (there’s you’re terrorist-protecting due process) and 6th could have been one big broad thing (even more so than the 1st) yet if tyranny sets in, you’ll enjoy none of those rights.
8th is about “cruel and unusual punishment” and while it’s not up for vote, it’s been voted down.
9th: States rights except when they don’t deserve them so that’s been voted down.
10th is something about the Constitution should be followed so that’s right out.
Our count this far is perhaps 4.5 (ETA without trying to sound like a guy on a box yelling things, I’ll have to lower my score to 3.0 / 10.0 and even there subject to Exec branch) of the first 10 count, subject to the approval of the Executive/DOJ branch, and if you’ve got to cash to pay court costs, you might reach SCOTUS of course.
The rest of the amendments free the slaves, ban liquor, allow liquor, allow women and soldiers who at the time in Viet-nam to vote and other boring stuff like how many terms a president can serve before he ascends to a lifetime presidency.
There will never be another amendment in my lifetime, unless it’s “Mars is Ours” (28th) and certainly 2/3rd’s of Americans will agree on that.