Okay I admit that I have been struggling with this question. You do remember the scene in Full Metal Jacket wherein the drill instructor drums into the recruits heads: “This is my rifle; this is my gun…”
And I always assumed everyone understood the point of this scene.
But do they? Let me explain why I have my doubts:
It began with an episode of Family Guy of all things. Stewie handles a shotgun (and he says it’s a shotgun; he says something like “I’ve never handled a ten guage before.”). And then he puts the shotgun to his shoulder and parodies the “this is my rifle; this is my gun.” scene from the movie.
Obviously a shotgun isn’t a rifle, so the Family Guy writers don’t understand the point of that scene from the movie! Before this, I assumed everyone got it.
So I started worrying that oh shit, maybe the population in general didn’t understand that scene? Maybe they just think it’s word salad and they don’t know the difference between a rifle and gun?
So please tell me I’m wrong. Most of you understand why Marines have to differentiate between guns and rifles, right?
What do *you *think the point of the scene is? Because when I watch that scene, I don’t get the impression it’s about differentiating between firearms at all.
The point is to drill Marines not to use the word “gun” when talking about their small arms. A gun is an artillery piece. Using one word for the other (e.g. on the radio or in a scouting report) could lead to confusion, which is already in ample supply in battle ;).
I always thought he was trying to impress on them that they need to be very specific with their terminology; they need to be in the habit of making their communication as unambiguous as possible. There’s no time for ambiguity in a combat situation.
That quote is from a risque ditty from WWII.
“This is my rifle, (indicating a firearm.) This is my gun. (indicating his penis) One is for killing, one is for fun.”
That’s how it is in the movie, too. Not being a military man, I still don’t get how identifying one’s rifle as being for fighting and one’s penis as being for fun easily (or at all) equates to a directive not to call a rifle a gun (or vice versa). :: shrug ::
My dad said that once when some Waves were visiting the ship and he was supposed to call hands to for small-arms inspection, he got on the PA and said ‘All hands stand to for short-arm inspection!’ The Waves started giggling. He thought he’d said something incorrectly… so he said it again!
(Knowing dad, I don’t know if this really happened. Could’ve been a sea story.)
It’s called negative reinforcement; supposedly, the march/chant/crotch grab was silly and/or humiliating to the recruits, therefore driving home the lesson to NOT be imprecise in terminology.
I’ve never handled a firearm in my life. My vague understanding is that the distinguishing characteristic of a rifle is a rifled barrel, which allows a more accurate shot. I’m not sure how, if at all, one should define a “gun”, much less how the various branches of the armed services might do so.
So I’m not sure whether I “get” the jingle or the Family Guy parody or not. If someone wants to explain about rifles and guns, I’m all ears. Just leave my schlong out of it.