This is the thread where we tell our adoption stories

I have a half-brother somewhere out there who was adopted out quite a few years before I was born. Mum was young, the father was apparently not at all interested in supporting her or the child, and there was only one option offered. Adopt the child out. There was no support from anyone for her to keep him. As far as I can tell adopting him out was just not the choice she would have made.

Now I live on another continent, and she doesn’t want to try to find him anyway, for all kinds of reasons, so it’d be selfish of me to open that up. But I do wonder. He was adopted to a couple who live in the same city my brother lives in. Is he still there?

I feel for Mum. During the early 70s, where I grew up, women who gave birth out of wedlock were treated coldly at best. There was absolutely no consideration for her feelings at all in the way things were handled. I’m not going to be the one who opens all this up for her. We’ve discussed it and if my half-brother wants to find us, she’s not doing anything to prevent it.

People have asked me how I can stand not knowing my half-sibling since I know he exists, but it’s not a lack of curiosity. It’s just that my desire to know doesn’t override my mother’s feelings. Can’t possibly override them. She was honest with us and I’ve known about it since I was about 10.

I hope it’s OK that I posted my adoption story since I’m a sibling not a parent or child, but it weighs on me from time to time that there’s this unknown family out there. I am so, so happy when I hear how much better the adoption process seems to be for the birth mothers these days in terms of the possibilities for open adoption, and a general recognition of birth-mothers’ emotions as being important.

[wicked persona] C’mon, lavenderlemon, have you ever met a " Fuji Kitakyusho " before?? :smiley: [/ wicked persona]

This thread is becoming something important to me. The things that are being shared are making me think very hard about what I live and how I parent, and making me grateful that I can listen to viewpoints that have nothing in common with my own.

The Punkyova, I too struggled with the issues you raise. In South Korea, at least 15 years ago, there was absolutely zero infrastructure to support a single mother. Shunned by family and culture, it was anathema. I truly felt that I was doing the right thing both for my own need to be a father, and for a child that would have lived in an orphanage. Or, to be honest since the adoption process in South Korea dates back to the end of the Korean War, the child would have been adopted by another American of Australian family. Still… there is the struggle.

The discussions that are most painful are the ones involving trips back to South Korea. We had one last year with the kids. Basically, we started to have them think about what the real dynamic would be of trying to find their birth mothers. We reminded them of how alien THEY feel when talking to a Korean woman who cannot communicate with them but for a few basic words. They have made it clear that they feel a weird mix of American and Korean and sometimes more one than the other. (I suspect that will not change until they are adults and they have found their place in the world ). I told them that they’d be facing a woman who could not talk to them most likely. ( yeah, I know. English is taught in the schools. But that’s a sop, because I have been to South Korea twice and unless it was someone who truly had learned and worked English, nobody could communicate with me, even if they badly wanted to ) I told the kids that the upset of meeting a stranger who they knew was their birth mom might be very painful for them, but if they wanted to try to do it during their college years, I would support them in that goal.

Not before that. There was a speaker a few years ago at the Korean Culture camp they attent. A korean adoptee, who had been taken to South Korea by her parents during high school, to find her birth mother. She made it clear that she- and many of her fellows who had shared their stories- was not emotionally capable of dealing with it at age 15. She begged those of us who were inclined to allow our children to seek their birth mothers to try to have them wait until they were well into college age. The maturity matters. I am inclined to agree.

I don’t feel threatened by the idea that they want to meet their birth mother. Then again, that’s easy for me to say. Their birth fathers disappeared, and so I likely wouldn’t feel a visceral threat where my wife might. But still… I have to step back and respect what they are going to go through for the rest of their lives. Loving them and supporting them unconditionally has to include helping them on that path, if they so chose it. Otherwise, it’d be terribly self-serving and selfish to try to prevent that search. Wouldn’t make me much of a father to deny them their true background and history. These are pretty strong personal feelings here, and I’m comfortable sharing them but please, don’t anyone feel I’m trying to impress those feelings upon anyone else. Everybody finds their own way .

Idlewild, I am glad you posted what you did. A few years ago, my daughter was sniffling and crying after I’d kissed her goodnight. I went back in and sat down and asked what was wrong. She said, " I wonder if I have any brothers ". I laughed ( unfortunately… ) and said yeah, he’s right next door and being too darned loud. She burst into tears afresh and said, " No, ** I mean other brothers** ". Duh, Cartoonidad. She and her brother had apparently been talking a lot that day about unknown siblings. She was mourning the loss of brothers and sisters she will likely never know. As I’m holding her, her brother walks in, already crying. It was one of those nights. I thanked her for saying it to me, for telling me what was so hard to say ( she was afraid of hurting my feelings ). I let them know that I’d always rather know these things, than not.

They will likely never know about siblings. That’s sad, but the reality. The South Korean government does not make such searches easy.

I was looking for her, but I had made a decision not to contact her first. I had always imagined her growing up with two loving adoptive parents and having a perfect life. I did not want to intrude in any way if that is what she wanted.

This sounds similar, except my daughter’s (I’ll call her K) adoptive mom abandoned her - she left when K was still a baby, and K was raised by her father. I still don’t know why someone would go through the adoption process and then leave, but from what I know about her she does have some issues. She returned and was in and out of K’s life while she was growing up, but they never got along very well. I do feel sometimes that she was looking for me for the reasons you state above - maybe finding me would make everything better. K has told me that she started seriously looking for me when she was 11.

My life has had some dramatic ups and downs, and I’m very afraid of letting her down and not living up to her expectations. The birth father’s family has welcomed her with open arms, and K has recently moved to be closer to them.

I have talked to her about my feelings and she does seem OK with that. Like I said, I am afraid of disappointing her and I really do want to be there for her. This is all still very new to me, so I am taking it slowly.

It’s interesting hearing from those who have adopted from Korea. A friend was adopted from Korea in 1970. She was raised in a white family with five white siblings. Her parents attempted to get her involved with the Korean community (what it was in Minneapolis at that time), but T never wanted to. She never wanted to identify herself as Korean. She did, however, make comments to me that I was lucky to be an adopted white kid. We went to church with all older Swedish people, she went to school in a white neighborhood… she didn’t want to focus on the fact that she was not white.

Fast forward a few deacdes, she’s now married to another Korean adoptee and they are involved in the Korean community in Milwaukee.

Adoptees:

Are you looking for your biological parents? If so, why (health, curiosity, children, etc.)?

No. My biological mother, I thought was my aunt all my life. I know who she is. She has two sons of her own now, my half-brothers, and honestly doesn’t much seem to care about me anymore. My biological father is dead and I only know a handful of facts about them.

Did you find them? What was the outcome?

See above.

Was the reunion what you thought it would be?

See above. There was no “reunion” obviously, instead, my bio-mom took me aside at a second cousin’s house and told me she was my real mom, that my adopted mom was being selfish so she had to tell me. Then disappeared for five + years.

How did your adoptive parents feel about it?

It terrified my mother, and for years she clamped down harder and harder on me. At the time I didn’t realize this was what was happening, and of course fought harder and harder. It made for a ton of friction, and is a big part of the reason my mom and I had a falling-out and haven’t spoken much for years. (We are working on trying to be at least friends, if not mother-daughter).

I am 110% for open adoptions for this reason, at least there are no icky surprises. I’m not bitter about it (anymore) but I do wish things could have been different.

I’ve thought about it briefly from the perspective of my adopted-out half brother but I mean, he has no way of knowing we (my brother and I) exist at all. And who knows if he cares or if he would even get anything out of knowing us? I don’t know if my brother cares at all or not. We don’t discuss it. I don’t bring it up with Mum any more. It makes me very happy to hear that your children feel comfortable discussing that with you. Of course it’s terribly sad for your children (and I don’t mean that in a platitudinous way), but it sounds like as a family you have the resilience, love and openness to deal with the reality, even though it is not an easy situation. It must mean so much to your children that you can give them the security of knowing they’re loved and wanted. I am now imagining it might have been harder for my half-brother too - which is harder, knowing that you have a sibling but not knowing them? Or just not knowing at all? Then again, maybe it’s all a closed book for him.

There’s a beautiful article in the NYT online today, a first person perspective on a birth mother being reunited with her son, and it gave me a lot more to think about. Between that and this thread, it’s bringing up some serious emotion. It’s definitely an honour to hear so many people’s personal stories.