Did the others think that Albert was already dead before the chance encounter on the street?
Were they on some sort of treasure hunt?
Does this in any way involve cannibalism?
Coldfire asks: Is it significant that Charlie encountered him first?
NO
SwimmingRiddles asks: The box contained a picture of felching?
EWWWW.
NO.
aschrott asks: was the original package some sort of blackmail?
NO
Coldfire asks: Was the package a message implying that Albert had died?
NO
Random asks: Are the five people (four after Albert’s death) living human beings?
YES
SwimmingRiddles asks: Were all members involved guests on the cruise? (ie: Albert was a cabin-boy, etc…)
YES
aschrott asks: did albert send them a hypnotic suggestion to kill him?
NO
Coldfire asks: Is it relevant that the names start with A, B, C, D, and E respectively?
NO
Coldfire asks: Is it relevant that they took a trip to the South Seas?
YES
Random asks: Did the others think that Albert was already dead before the chance encounter on the street?
NO
Coldfire asks: Were they on some sort of treasure hunt?
NO
waterj2 asks: Does this in any way involve cannibalism?
YES
Was the group involved in illegal/illicit activities in the South Seas? Did they ever get off the boat while in the South Seas, and is it relevant?
would Albert have expected the other four men to kill him?
Was Albert a cannibal? Did he have evidence the others were? (I know that counts as blackmail, but…)
Coldfire asks: Is it significant that Charlie encountered him first?
NO
SwimmingRiddles asks: The box contained a picture of felching?
EWWWW.
NO.
aschrott asks: was the original package some sort of blackmail?
NO
Coldfire asks: Was the package a message implying that Albert had died?
NO
Random asks: Are the five people (four after Albert’s death) living human beings?
YES
SwimmingRiddles asks: Were all members involved guests on the cruise? (ie: Albert was a cabin-boy, etc…)
YES
aschrott asks: did albert send them a hypnotic suggestion to kill him?
NO
Coldfire asks: Is it relevant that the names start with A, B, C, D, and E respectively?
NO
Coldfire asks: Is it relevant that they took a trip to the South Seas?
YES
Random asks: Did the others think that Albert was already dead before the chance encounter on the street?
NO
Coldfire asks: Were they on some sort of treasure hunt?
NO
waterj2 asks: Does this in any way involve cannibalism?
YES
SwimmingRiddles asks: Was the group involved in illegal/illicit activities in the South Seas?
YES, in a manner of speaking
SwimmingRiddles asks: Did they ever get off the boat while in the South Seas?
YES
SwimmingRiddles asks: and is it relevant [that they got off the boat while the South Seas]?
YES
Did the package contain body parts of the murderers? Was this a revenge killing?
Do each of the men know what happened to the package after they saw and forwarded it?
Specifically, do they know that Edward threw the package away?
Were the other four expecting the box?
aschrott asks: would Albert have expected the other four men to kill him?
YES
SwimmingRiddles asks: Was Albert a cannibal?
YES
SwimmingRiddles asks: Did he have evidence the others were [cannibals]? (I know that counts as blackmail, but…)
YES
Are all five men cannibals?
Random asks: Did the package contain body parts of the murderers?
NO
Random asks: Was this a revenge killing?
In a sense… YES
SingleDad asks: Do each of the men know what happened to the package after they saw and forwarded it? Specifically, do they know that Edward threw the package away?
YES
SwimmingRiddles asks: Were the other four expecting the box?
YES
Was there a 6th member of the cruise party that was eaten?
If not, did they eat a townie?
Would they have wanted to kill Albert before Charlie met him?
Would they have wanted to kill Albert had they not seen the contents of the box?
SwimmingRiddles asks: Was there a 6th member of the cruise party that was eaten?
NO
SwimmingRiddles asks: If not, did they eat a townie?
NO
SingleDad asks: Are all five men cannibals?
YES
Was the decision to kill Albert based solely on the discussion with Charlie?
If so, was it because he was expressing remorse for what they had done?
SingleDad asks:
Would they have wanted to kill Albert before Charlie met him?
NO
SingleDad asks: Would they have wanted to kill Albert had they not seen the contents of the box?
YES
was Albert aware that Charlie had seen him on the street?
Did they talk to one another?