Three Year Olds Don't Tell Funny Jokes

Last night I finally remembered the entire joke as told by Tenley, aged (barely) three, this Christmas. I had just taught the older kids the “impatient cow” knock-knock joke, which they thought was a riot. Tenley, of course, laughed with the others and wanted to join them as they repeated it to other people. She came up to me with a big grin–

Tenley: Knock knock!
Wendy: Who’s there?
Tenley (with single hop for emphasis): Cow!
Wendy: Cow who?
Tenley: (long pause, grin becomes uncertain, then her eyes brighten) Door! Ha ha ha ha!

My 2 and a half year old niece thinks it’s hilarious to knock on her mother’s head shouting ‘No Brains, No Brains!’. No one knows where she got it from. She also like to say ‘I’ll tell you a secret’ and then starts whispering into your ear to lull you into a false sense of security before shouting ayayayayayayaaaa in your ear and then rolling around the place laughing.

As a three-year old it seems I was singularly lacking in humour however. My mother’s cousin always tells me of the time she brought me on a walk in the countryside when we saw a beautiful red deer (think bambi) bounding over the ferns. She pointed it out to me excitedly. I just replied supercilliously ‘I’ve seen cows before!’ - It had her in stitches though.

Also once I was watching a kids’ programme called Playschool (British and Irish Dopers will remember this) on our old black and white TV and the presenter was drawing a picture and as she was drawing she was saying ‘Now we’ll use the GREEN crayon to draw a big, green tree and now the RED crayon to draw a nice, red car…’ and I jumped up and shouted indignantly ‘THAT’S NOT RED. IT’S ALL GREY!!!’ This cracked my mother up. We bought a colour TV not long afterwards. I guess she felt guilty… :slight_smile:

I read somewhere that all you have to say to young teenage boys to get them started on an uncontrollable giggle fit is “Fart” or “Poop.”

As a mother of an almost 14 year old, I can attest to the power of these words. No matter how pissed off or down in the dumps my son is, all I have to do to get him out of his funk is place my hands gently on his shoulders, look him deep in the eye, and say softly,

“Poop.”

Works every time.

Which is why Macs used to offer (OS 9) an alert sound that was a little kid’s giggle, and when you set it as your alert, it would randomly play every 15 or 20 minutes when the computer was running. Never failed to make me smile! Dumped in OS X, for some (no doubt curmudgeonly) reason…

My five-year-old son likes to tell me a joke every night at bedtime. Now, he’s been doing this for about six months now, so, without any new jokes coming into the rotation, so you’d think we’d both be bored with it, right?

Ah, but you didn’t count on the power of joke mutation! The L’il Swoggler (LS for short) started off with the usual “Why did the chicken cross the road?” – an old standby, always popular. But, whenever I give him an answer, his punchline changes. As with everybody else’s kids, it doesn’t make much sense, but it changes.

These days, it goes something like this:

LS: Daddy, why did the cow cross the road?
GBH: I don’t know, why?
LS: To get to the cow-cow!
GBH: <polite fake laughter> Well, goodnight sweetie. Sleep tight.
LS: Wait, Daddy! What about the second joke?
GBH: OK. <waits>
LS: Why did the cow cross the road?
GBH: Because it was tired?
LS: No, silly – to get to the mauw-mauw!

He gets the timing of a punchline – he sells it the right way, and all that – but he doesn’t seem to have realized that a punchline is supposed to do things like make sense or even contain recognizable words.

And he goes to kindergarten in a month and a half – who knows what that will do to his sense of humor…

Mickey Mouse’s underwear. That’s what it will do to his sense of humor. It happens to every generation of kindergartener.

Hee hee. That reminds me of the time my uncle was talking about a tour he took of a military ship. He gets to the part where he was taken onto the poop deck, and my listening ten-year-old cousin breaks in in a delighted, unbelieving voice, “Poop deck?” And he was into a long fit of giggles after that. What I wouldn’t give for a recording of the way he repeated “poop deck.”

Typical Cranky Jr joke:

Q. Why did the penguin eat the crocodile?

A. Because the polar bear was on the airplane!

He says the latter line with the kind of sing-song emphasis you’d use for someone who asked an obvious question, but he’s grinning the whole time.

He’s gotten a little better lately. He now prefaces all jokes with the declaration, “JOKE TIME!” and then it’ll go more like:

Q. Why did the penguin eat the crocodile?

A. Because it was lunch!

Still not funny, but a little more logical.

Imagine me as a five-year-old kid, lying in the upper bunkbed, staring at the ceiling in the middle of the night, mind a-whirl. (I started early with that.)

Suddenly, a thought strikes me, and I sit bolt upright.

“MOOOOMMMMM! DAAAAAAD!” I’m shouting at the top of my lungs. You’d think the bed was being invaded by bloodthirsty groin beetles. “MOOOOMMMMMMMMMMM! DAAAAAAD!”

After a couple of minutes, I hear thumping footsteps in the hallway, and my mother and father, looking distressed and quite disheveled, burst into the room, slapping the switch to turn on the light.

“What? What?” they say breathlessly, clearly expecting me to be on fire.

Instead, in all innocence, in a perfectly calm tone of voice, I take a deep breath and say this: “What do you get when you cross a vegetable with a stinging insect?”

I have a clear memory of my parents staring at me, dumbfounded, as their jaws slowly go slack.

Finally my mother says, quite deliberately, quite politely: “I don’t know. What?”

Me, proudly: “Bumble bean!”

They blink at me for a moment, then my mother says, “That’s very clever. Did you make that up?”

Me: “Yep.”

Her: “Good. Go back to sleep.”

I lay back down, still proud, and they turn off the light and leave. Nothing is ever said of it again.

It’s one of my earliest complete memories — complete, meaning it lasts more than two seconds, or more than a single image. I’m quite fond of it; I think it provides remarkable insight into the development of my adult personality. :smiley:

Somewhere, my mother has a cassette on which the four-year-old me is trying valiantly to sing a preschool song I don’t quite know all the words to, at least beyond the opening, “Abraham Lincoln, kind and true,” while my two-year-old brother, just on the cusp of being lingual, keeps interrupting with a high-pitched “EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE.” It’s almost magical how it’s unbearably adorable and teeth-grindingly annoying all at the same time.

Eliminated! Hahaha!

(Preschool humour goes so much farther when you’ve got an adult’s vocabulary.)

My friend’s daughter was 5 when A Bug’s Life came out. She was hysterically laughing for 15 minutes after the pupu platter scene with the dung beetles.

Another friend’s 2-3 year old daughter and I would entertain ourselves by engaging in the most intellectual of debates. After about the 7th reiteration of our initial positions (“My blanket!” “No, my blanket!”) I’d reverse my initial position just to have her switch (“No, it’s your blanket!” “No, it’s YOUR blanket!” “Okay, it’s my blanket. Thanks sweetheart.”)

The Bugs Bunny School Of Debate doesn’t fly 'round here, unfortunately. If it’s hers, it’s hers, and if it’s mine, it’s hers. Her position on this issue is immune to such logic.

However, since I’m bigger than her, I can force the issue when she’s laid claim to something like scissors or cleaning products.

After carefully explaining the concept of the “knock knock” joke to my 3YO niece…
Me: Knock knock
Niece: DADDY! LOCK THE DOOR!

Very funny, kid.

OK… when my oldest was 3 or 4, we decided to expose him to Opera (they say you either love it or hate it & we didn’t which one it would be). The park by our house has free operas which are put on by local opera houses, so we took a blanket & a picnic basket and headed over.

When we got there, it was quite crowded and everyone seemed to have that ‘mensa gaze’ on while listening to the music. ( Think of ‘mensa gaze’ as that look your father got everytime he waited 5 minutes to make a move in chess) Well, we set out the blanket, and tell my my boy “That music you hear? That’s Opera!”

He had a blank expression on his face for a minute, and then started swiveling his head around like he was searching for something.

“Where are they?”, he said simply.

Now it was crowded that day & we were 2 ballfields away from that band shell, so I picked him up and pointed.

“No, Daddy, where are they?” he said again.

I gestured again, but this obviously wasn’t what he was looking for. Finally, I put him down, looked him in the eye and asked,

“Where are Who, Michael?”

To which he replied with a totally straight face and a loud toddler voice, “The Singing Gorillas! Where are the Singing Gorillas, Daddy?”.

I can’t remember a day where I’ve ever folded up a blanket and walked back home from that park faster…

My cousin was just learning about jokes when he came up with this family gem…

“Why did the horse climb up the tree?”
“Because it was his home!”

Close… but no cigar.

One of my earliest memories is telling this joke while on vacation with my parents:

Me: Knock knock.
Parent: Who’s there?
Me: Apple.
Parent: Apple Who?
Me: Apple tree.

Perfectly awful; it doesn’t even have that surreal element that others possess. Even worse, I repeated it with all my favorite fruits. Suddenly there were strawberry trees and grape trees…

Doesn’t hold a candle to my incredible sense of humor today… :ahem:

OK - picture this.

I’m 5 years old. Dad has decided to sell our house and move several miles away to put me in a better school district when I start kindergarten. So our real estate agent is holding an open house at our place.

I’m next door with the neighbors - to get me out of the house, obviously. I’m sitting at their kitchen table eating cookies and drinking a big glass of milk. The neighbor says to something to me about the open house. I look up and the back door of our house is wide open, so I point to the door and say:

“That really IS an open house, isn’t it?”

The neighbor started laughing, and I discovered the joy of a well-placed and unexpected punchline. Too bad I didn’t learn my lesson well enough…

My sisters and cousins used to like to tape themselves on my mom’s ancient portable tape deck. They were all older than me and much quicker with the comedy. They’d make up commercial parodies and contests (my sister had one about winning a burnt-down barn if you sent in the itchy tags from your brassieres), or be “sportscasters” and describe the Atari Grand Prix game that was going on in the background, and perform pretend soap operas about the Underground Railroad. Let’s just say there was a lot of lead paint in the old houses we lived in, ok?

When it came time for me to step up to the mic and say something funny, this was my contribution, at age 3:

There’s a fart in my cart
There’s a foo-foo in my tu-tu

What’s worse is, I never had a tiny little kid voice. I have a non-girlish timbre, and it sounds like I’m about 15 saying that ridiculous rhyme, mumbling into the speaker so that “tu-tu” sounds like “choo-choo”.

I’ve never lived this phrase down and it is oft repeated with glee, usually during holiday dinners.

I can categorically say that would be the most disturbing thing I could imagine hearing randomly. I’d be frantically looking around for the children of the corn who are hiding in my closet. Or under my bed.
Anyway, it would be scary.

I must go get me a child, and make it tell jokes.

I have not laughed to the point of tears in weeks, as I have laughed here today.

oh, little boy, what’s your favourite joke? No, wait, don’t run away …

Guess what?

Monkey Butt!!! <giggles>