[QUOTE=Least Original User Name Ever]
Originally Posted by I Don’t Even Know Who Anymore
The nativism is all on the other side as well. MECHA and others think that since the Southwest used to be part of Mexico, that they therefore have a right to live where they and their ancestors never lived just because it had once been part of that country. For those who subscribe to that kind of argument, I hope that they will extend it to more than just Mexicans. In that case, Russians can emmigrate to the US since they have that right, since Alaska used to be Russian. Or we should just let Russians charter some boats and come across to Alaska and then to the US since the Russian settlements went down the US coast as well. Such folks will get great support from the neo-Nazis in Germany since they want to restore all of what was historically and until very recently East Prussia to Germany. After WWII millions of Germans who had been there for centuries were forced from their homes and lands, as East Prussia was divided between Poland and Russia. The MECHAs and the German neo-Nazis have a lot in common.
I’m not against this at all. Actually, I think I’ve argued for it in this thread and others as well. If the problem is that some Mexicans see the land in the Southwest as their ancestral land (but have no paper trail to back it up) and you can provide a useful solution to it, then you’re WELL on the way to a Nobel Peace prize. This Mexican/American solution could be taken to help the Native American/Federal government situation, and even the Israel/Palestine problem, for there are eerily similar claims for those situations.
There is a solution to this problem, it is called enforcing the law and building the fence. I can care less what an idiot may think if he says he owns my home because his nationality used to claim it as part of his country. I do care when he tries to take my home or claim that he has the same right of citizenship as I have.
None of the illegals were born in the US, otherwise they would not be illegals.
That is unlike the Israeli-Palestinian situation where hundreds of thousands of Palestinians were born in what is now Israel. Native Americans are also citizens of the US as well now and have been for almost a century. I see no similarity there unless you are racist and think that because your race once occupied some ground that it is yours by right forever. The current MECHAs types would think that Hitler was right in demanding the Sudentenland be returned to Germany. Those lands had been taken from Germany after WWI and had a majority German population as well and given to Czechoslovakia. There is a big difference between that and the situation in the Southwest US. NOne of the current illegals have ever lived as citizens there at any time prior to the change of the border. Unlike the Sudeten Germans who had lived there for centuries and had at one time been German citizens.
Note how the “wall” for Native Americans is pushing them to reservations. What kind of problems has that caused?
I didn’t know that Native Americans were not citizens and could not leave the reservations. Is that your contention?
There is a very real wall build by Israel. How well is that working for them? How many resources do they have to divert to that wall? If “good fences make good neighbors”, how come Israel and Palestine don’t dine at the same table?(metaphorically speaking, of course.)
If the peace agreements are ever worked out, they will have some peace there. The problem with the Israeli fence is that it is unilaterraly imposed and perhaps a majority of the Palestinians have lived in the place that is now Israel. Also if you will note that part of the agreement or problem is to reject the claims of the right of return for Palestinians who once lived in Israeli territory. I don’t think you would claim that the illegals all once lived in the US. After those agreements are signed, will the disposessed Palestinians still have the right to reclaim their homes and lands? I don’t think so. So why say that folks who never lived in the US somehow have a right by virtue of race or nationality to be here?
Both of those “solutions” aren’t. These three problems aren’t perfectly aligned, but there are shades of those problems in each of these instances. How do you get peace between Israel and Palestine? You need to reform the system. How can we start getting some useful solution out of our mishandling of the Natives? Coming up with a new solution that includes changing how they’re treated.
How do we fix this border problem? Make immigration and free flow of people through borders very easy and overhaul the system. Augment welfare. Embrace a second language, don’t stifle it. As Eddie Izzard said “the Dutch speak 4 languages and smoke marijuana. Yeah? Well they’re cheating!” Times change, people change, and problems arise when the system doesn’t change with those times. This is the time (actually, it’s past the time).
[/QUOTE]
Well you should preach to Mexico to do that. They sure as hell don’t allow any of their latin american brothers to stay in Mexico and they sure won’t pay even medical treatment for them if they are dying. I already speak TWO languages and a good part of a third. The Dutch and the rest of Europe don’t have open borders either by the way. I know because I have tried to get work there and even though I am one of a few qualified in my area of work, they will not let me work there.