[QUOTE=FinnAgain]
I’m not sure I can agree. In my mind’s eye, it seems that his only motive is to rant and/or rave against religion. He does it via methods that are often hostile, and much of the time ends up pissing people off. Which is why I might (possibly) agree that his behavior is jerkish, but I don’t see it as trollish.
I’m wary of ascribing malice to his style, if only because I know that almost any discussion over religion will end up having people go berserk.
Pointing out that, for instance, that there’s no more reason to believe in the Abrahamic God over, say, Zeus? And that past civilizations have believed in things varying from pixies to spirits and used them to explain reality, but that we don’t credit them as viable these days? Well… it can and often does lead to some-but-not-all religious folks having total meltdowns.
It seems that some of the best arguments about the certainty (or lack thereof) of supernatural belief will, almost without fail, wind up making some people froth at the mouth and go straight into attack mode. I’m wary about outlawing any of those tactics simply because some folks will go crazy when they’re used.
Then again, my opinion counts for nothing in modly circles.
[/QUOTE]
Nor does mine, of course. And I’m not advocating banning badchad, or even calling him a troll. Your point about how easily some believers can melt down when their beliefs are compared to belief in Zeus or in unicorns really captures the essence of my objection to badchad’s behavior. He frequently chooses the most provocative and inflammatory words at his disposal to make whatever point he’s trying to make. It is possible, even easy, for you to politely outline a reasonable comparison of belief in the Abrahamic God to belief in Zeus. Somehow you managed to not call Jesus a cunt while doing it. It is also possible and easy for me to explain that my beliefs are not scientifically verifiable, that they are in part a result of the convincing (to me) testimony of other believers and on personal spiritual experiences, and that they do not, for me, involve any conflict with science. Important matters can cause meltdowns, and we shouldn’t be so intent on politeness and avoiding offence that we render our discussions bland, but in my view badchad deliberately inflames feelings that are already prone to overheating.
or you therefore have to accept that your entire balance depends on a Type Y (::forces center of gravity around deliberately chosen pivot point: