I always interpreted that as posters who just kept causing problems, who constantly require moderator attention. I wouldn’t have thought it would apply to someone who rarely posts.
The main problem I had is that this one in particular seems a bit like it’s fetish fuel, and there is a rule against that. And it cast all their previous posts in a different light. And, yeah, that’s kinda creepy and unwanted.
Not saying I disagree with modding him. Just that I thought that rule was for a different situation, basically posters who would try to ride the line.