Ultimate 10: Favorite Christmas Carols

[Prof.Pepperwinkle]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 6
3. Little Drummer Boy - 3
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 5
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 4
9. Coventry Carol - 5
10. Silent Night - 5
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 7
13. I Wonder As I Wander - 3
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 5
17. Carol of the Bells - 5

[Art_Rock]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 6
3. Little Drummer Boy - 3
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 5
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 4
9. Coventry Carol - 5
10. Silent Night - 5
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 7
13. I Wonder As I Wander - 2
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 6
17. Carol of the Bells - 5

[atimnie]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 6
3. Little Drummer Boy - 4
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 5
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 4
9. Coventry Carol - 5
10. Silent Night - 5
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 7
13. I Wonder As I Wander - 2
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 5
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 6
17. Carol of the Bells - 5

[panache45]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 6
3. Little Drummer Boy - 4
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 5
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 4
9. Coventry Carol - 5
10. Silent Night - 5
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 7
13. I Wonder As I Wander - 1
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 6
17. Carol of the Bells - 5

[Prof.Pepperwinkle]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 6
3. Little Drummer Boy - 4
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 5
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 4
9. Coventry Carol - 5
10. Silent Night - 6
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. I Wonder As I Wander - 1
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 6
17. Carol of the Bells - 5

[Aspidistra]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 6
3. Little Drummer Boy - 4
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 5
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 5
10. Silent Night - 6
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. I Wonder As I Wander - 2
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 6
17. Carol of the Bells - 5

[panache45]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 7
3. Little Drummer Boy - 4
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 5
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 5
10. Silent Night - 6
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. I Wonder As I Wander - 1
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 6
17. Carol of the Bells - 5

[Biotop]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 8
3. Little Drummer Boy - 4
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 5
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 5
10. Silent Night - 6
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. I Wonder As I Wander - 1
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 5
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 6
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5

[Dead_Cat]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 8
3. Little Drummer Boy - 4
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 4
10. Silent Night - 6
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. I Wonder As I Wander - 1
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 5
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 6
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5
19. Once in Royal David’s City - 5

I’ve never played this before, so assumed the rules were: add 1 to the score of exactly one item on the list. Deduct 1 from the score of exactly one item on the list. (Optionally) add a new item to the list with a starting score of 5. Did I deduce correctly?

[panache45]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 8
3. Little Drummer Boy - 4
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 4
10. Silent Night - 6
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. I Wonder As I Wander - 0
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 6
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5
19. Once in Royal David’s City - 5

I think all three (promoting, demoting, adding) are optional. You can do just one, two or all three. Am I right?

[Prof.Pepperwinkle]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 8
3. Little Drummer Boy - 4
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 4
10. Silent Night - 7
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. I Wonder As I Wander - 0
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 6
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5
19. Once in Royal David’s City - 4

[atimnie]

Those are the rules, plus no consecutive posts or sandwich posting.
Update, NOT a game post

Zero list

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer
I Wonder As I Wander
Safe list

1. Handel: Messiah: Hallelujah Chorus
   Revised list

2. The First Noel - 6

3. O Holy Night - 8

4. Little Drummer Boy - 4

5. Away in a Manger - 6

6. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6

7. Riu Riu Chiu - 4

8. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6

9. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3

10. Coventry Carol - 4

11. Silent Night - 7

12. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5

13. We Three Kings - 6

14. Once in Royal David’s City - 4

15. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5

16. Sleigh Ride - 6

17. In the Bleak Midwinter - 6

18. Carol of the Bells - 5

19. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5

[atimnie]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 8
3. Little Drummer Boy - 5
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 4
10. Silent Night - 7
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. Once in Royal David’s City - 4
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 5
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5
19. Mary’s Boy Child - 5

[panache45]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 9
3. Little Drummer Boy - 5
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 4
10. Silent Night - 7
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. Once in Royal David’s City - 4
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 4
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5
19. Mary’s Boy Child - 5

[Dead_Cat]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 9
3. Little Drummer Boy - 5
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 3
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 4
10. Silent Night - 7
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. Once in Royal David’s City - 4
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 5
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5
19. Mary’s Boy Child - 5

[Prof.Pepperwinkle]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 9
3. Little Drummer Boy - 5
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 4
10. Silent Night - 8
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. Once in Royal David’s City - 3
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 6
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 4
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5
19. Mary’s Boy Child - 5

[panache45]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 9
3. Little Drummer Boy - 5
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 4
10. Silent Night - 7
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. Once in Royal David’s City - 3
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 5
15. Sleigh Ride - 7
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 4
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5
19. Mary’s Boy Child - 5

[Dead_Cat]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 9
3. Little Drummer Boy - 5
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 3
10. Silent Night - 7
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. Once in Royal David’s City - 3
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 6
15. Sleigh Ride - 7
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 4
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5
19. Mary’s Boy Child - 5
20. It Came Upon a Midnight Clear - 5

[Prof.Pepperwinkle]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 9
3. Little Drummer Boy - 4
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 3
10. Silent Night - 8
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. Once in Royal David’s City - 3
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 6
15. Sleigh Ride - 7
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 4
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5
19. Mary’s Boy Child - 5
20. It Came Upon a Midnight Clear - 5

[atimnie]

1. The First Noel - 6
2. O Holy Night - 10
3. Little Drummer Boy - 4
4. Away in a Manger - 6
5. O Little Town of Bethlehem - 6
6. Riu Riu Chiu - 4
7. Hark the Herald Angels Sing - 6
8. Angels We Have Heard On High - 3
9. Coventry Carol - 3
10. Silent Night - 8
11. O Come, O Come, Emmanuel - 5
12. We Three Kings - 6
13. Once in Royal David’s City - 3
14. O Come, All Ye Faithful - 6
15. Sleigh Ride - 7
16. In the Bleak Midwinter - 3
17. Carol of the Bells - 5
18. God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen - 5
19. Mary’s Boy Child - 5
20. It Came Upon a Midnight Clear - 5