In another thread there are comments like ‘[J]ust give me [traditional] carols and maybe some modern arrangements thereof’, ‘[M]y personal favorite [Christmas carol] is “Good King Wenceslas”’, ‘* rather [enjoy] a carol service’. What is your favourite Christmas carol?
Here’s mine, as I learned it in high school:
♫ Herbei, o ihr Gläubigen,
Fröhlich triumphierend,
O kommet, o kommet nach Bethlehem!
Sehet das Kindlein,
Uns zum Heil geboren!
O lasset uns anbeten,
O lasset uns anbeten,
O lasset uns anbeten
Den König! ♫
It’s not a carol, but I also like Christmas Wrapping by The Waitresses.
I kind of like that one. Kind of. But as a child, I didn’t like the 1968 Rankin/Bass Christmas special. Something about the way the kid’s lip was animated, or how very earnest they made him (which was the point, after all). I grew up with Santa Claus and Christmas trees. TLDB was just a bit too religious for me, even at that young age. Kind of spoiled the song for me.
A couple/few months ago I watched The Greatest Gift (1942) on TCM. It’s a retelling of Le Jongleur de Notre Dame, first published in 1892, and based on a medieval French legend. The Little Drummer Boy is the same story, except that the ‘original’ involves a juggler-turned-monk who didn’t have a gift for the statue of the Virgin Mary. All he had was his ability to juggle. After fervently juggling for the statue (much to the consternation of the other monks), the statue comes to life and blesses him.
Adeste Fidelis. “O Come All ye Faithful” in the original Latin. I memorized it even before I became an altar boy, and I always find it fun to sing at Midnight Mass.
No, the ones that aren’t religious folk songs or popular hymns aren’t carols. It’s kind of a weak argument to drag in the dictionary definition just to say that it’s wrong.
The line between a Christmas Carol and a Christmas song is fuzzy and fine.
Then when you add in that around half of the music played is simply seasonal, and doesn’t even mention Christmas… and then there’s* a few of “My Favorite things”*…