Who are good authors you think match each other’s weak spots? Would they actually work well together, or would it be a case of too many cooks spoil the broth?
I’m sure this has been done before, but not for a while (I hope).
For example, I’ll list some IMHO strong and weak points of some authors. (I’ll do the children’s fantasy genre, why not?)
Piers Anthony: Some good ideas, nice effort with consistancy of magic in some places, some good plots, absolutely abysmal writing style.
Philip Pullman: Beautiful ideas and telling, mish-mash of plot and ideas at the end.
J. K. Rowling: Good world, good stories, exciting plots but ill-thought out magic leads to big holes at the end.
Could we combine any authors and get a book with a coherant plot, well thought out and beautiful world and interesting characters?
Probably not. (Oh, and I bet the second post is someone saying X is perfect already. Why not) (And it’s OK to think my examples suck. Better them)