Universal Healthcare: Public Option vs Single Payer

With Democrats winning the House and Senate and setting their sights on 2028, the discussion about how to implement universal healthcare has arisen once again.

I have been noticing a few different terms thrown about in these discussions. Interestingly, it seems like some people (perhaps the majority?) are using them interchangeably out of ignorance, others are very careful to make the distinction, and others seem to alternate between clearly defining a distinction and blurring it, depending on whether they want to disown someone for insufficient ideological purity or to claim someone as a supporter of their preferred policy.

For this thread, I’m less interested in debating the pros and cons of the different alternatives - I think that’s definitely worth a separate thread, but only after we can agree on definitions.

It seems to me that there is a clear distinction here, and I’ll define the relevant terms as I see them; I am curious to see if others agree with how I’ve laid these out.

Universal Healthcare - this is the umbrella term for any policy which will make it so that everyone has coverage for some sort of healthcare. This option has almost universal support among Democrats; I can’t think of a single official who opposes it.

Public Option - this is the least radical way to achieve universal healthcare. This keeps our current system with companies offering insurance, but either through Medicare or a novel system, the government will offer a public option (title drop) to those who don’t have healthcare through other means.

Single Payer - this is a system where we abolish the current system with private companies offering insurance. Instead the government is the only one that offers insurance. This is akin to the British IHS system, and is more extreme than what many European countries (Germany, France, etc) have.

Medicare For All (M4A) - This is a specific proposal championed by Bernie, AOC, and the other members of the Medicare For All Caucus which currently has 58 members. This proposal calls for a single payer system that (unlike the IHS or any other comparable European system) would also include dental and vision coverage. It would basically eliminate and replace the entire health insurance industry. It doesn’t outright ban supplemental insurance, but since M4A goes so much further than the IHS, there isn’t really any room left for supplemental insurance - basically just elective cosmetic surgery, private hospital rooms, and out of country treatments.

I think this distinction is important to make. For example, I recently saw someone post a video of Talarico talking about universal healthcare, and they captioned it “Talarico shifts to supporting M4A!”. But Talarico wasn’t shifting at all - he’s always supported universal healthcare through a public option - and in the video he was certainly not in favor of the M4A plan.

No, the UK NHS isn’t an insurance scheme, nor does it exclude private provision. It is a largely tax-funded public service, owning and running hospitals and specialist care, and sub-contracting primary care to mainly self-employed group practices. About 10% of medical care is paid for and provided privately. Though yes, this is more radical than perhaps most Americans would wish for.

Actually the big thing it can offer is beating the queue. There are all kinds of delays in the U.S. health care system, waiting to get into see the doctor, waiting for surgery, etc. A lot of patients would be willing to pay extra for prompt access.

The VA system in the US is very similar to the NHS, with the hospitals owned by the government and the healthcare providers working directly for the government.

OP, the problem is that Medicare is a single payer system and expanding Medicare might be a way of providing a public option, so I find your choices confusing.

A lot of patients would be willing to pay extra for that, but under the Medicare for All proposal, which bans duplicative coverage, they would not in fact be able to do so.

Medicare is only one kind of single payer system. My understanding is that Germany and a couple of other European countries have single payer with private insurance – you choose the insurance company, the government pays the bills.

Do you want to specifically only talk about MfA vs. adding Medicare as a public option?

Germany is definitely not single payer. They have competing, private, not-for-profit sickness funds called Krankenkassen.

As far as I am aware those are the only universal healthcare proposals seriously floated by American politicians in the Democratic party. I’m not aware of someone suggesting we bring the Krankenkassen system to the US, for example. If there are any proposals for universal coverage promoted by Democrats, or even any prominent Democrats who don’t want universal coverage but favor some other proposal, I am happy to hear about those as well.

The only realistic way the US will move closer to universal healthcare, if that’s what you want this thread to be about, would be through strengthening the ACA and adding a public option like Medicare that people can buy into instead of the private plans.

If more and more people flocked to Medicare because it was cheaper or better or both, then I could imagine moving to a MfA system, although I don’t see why it has to eliminate all private plans. I think Bernie is wasting his time with that requirement.

When the Dems had a filibuster-proof majority (when they were developing the ACA), they still couldn’t include a public option or MfA – the insurance lobby is very powerful. Now that people understand that the ACA is really quite good and efforts to eliminate it have fallen flat, the Dems can make marginal changes to make it better and cover more people, get rid of the donut, add the public option, etc. If they went all in on MfA, they would blow up their political capital and it still wouldn’t pass.

I am on the same page as you with almost all of that, but that’s not exactly what I want to investigate in this thread. In a follow-up thread about which of these options we should take, I would make many of the same arguments you just made.

What I’m interesting in this thread is figuring out if we all actually agree that these are the different camps and that the distinction between them actually matters, because I see people saying things like “Talarico is clearly a progressive, he supports Medicare for All” when he flat out does not support that, he supports a public option.

But I think people often say “Medicare for All” when they mean “Universal Healthcare”, and vice versa.

I see. I think anyone pushing towards more universal coverage is pretty progressive. If his (Talerico’s) steps include interim steps that work within the system without making an enemy of the insurance industry and the AMA, I would call him a smart, practical progressive.

Jumping straight to MfA as the only solution makes someone an impractical progressive.

I think Krugman, who is smart and progressive IMO, advocates for interim steps, with the end goal of potentially being MfA if that’s what looks like it would eventually work best.

In the meantime, there are millions losing coverage right now, so whatever interim steps we can take to shore up the existing system and possibly expand it will save a lot more lives than the purity test version.

All that said, I don’t know where basically any politician stands on this, so I’ll bow out.

As others have said, theres also providers and payers.

Some health systems like the VA and NHS has both public providers and public payers

Systems like medicare in the US have public payers, but private providers

Systems like the ACA exchanges or the system in the Netherlands have private payers and private providers.

What does matter is this. While other developed nations have a wide range of systems to provide UHC, one thing they all do is provide UHC while only spending about 10-12% of GDP while the US spends 18% of GDP on an inferior system.

Regarding terminology in the US, there are other aspects I’d include.

Public option - a public plan as an alternative to buying a private insurance plan

Medicare buy in - Giving people the option to buy into medicare

Changing the medicare age - mandating everyone over age 50 or 55 be entered into medicare

Medicare extra for all - The ACA, but all the uninsured are auto enrolled into a public system like medicare or medicaid

Medicare for all - medicare for everyone

But also uninsurance and underinsurance are factors in UHC. In the US a person may have insurance but if they make 40k a year and their insurance has a 10k deductible and a 20k OOPM, they really don’t have health care.

Meanwhile in some nations with underfunded UHC systems everyone on paper has UHC, but the wait time may be months which means they can’t get care when they need it.

Fundamentally the real problem with American health care is that its overpriced. We spend 18% of our economy for inferior results vs nations that spend 9-12% of their economy on health insurance.

People say medicare will save a lot of money. Andi n some way it will. It will streamline administration which will save hundreds of billions a year. And thats good.

But medicare for all also saves money but reducing reimbursement rates for providers. The problem is about half of all hospitals operate in the red. If you cut their reimbursement rates, those hospitals will close unless they get funding from somewhere else.

In states which have created a public option tied to things like medicare/medicaid, my understanding is they had to raise the reimbursement rates so providers would take it.

There is no obvious-to-me reason that a government administered plan would be significantly more efficient than a large non-profit Blue Cross plan.

True, today, there is a big difference between a good Blue Cross plan, and Medicare Parts A and B. With pure Medicare, there is little in the way of preauthorization requirements, but hardly anyone is going to choose unnecessary care because of ruinous copays (you are responsible to pay 20 percent coinsurance after the deductible). So the great majority, who are in Medicare, have a private supplement (could be for-profit, could be non-profit) that reduces or sometimes eliminates copayments, but requires doctors to justify expensive care that may or may not work, annoying the doctors who have to explain that some treatments you can read about on the internet are denied by insurers (often for excellent reasons).

I see three problems that should be fixed.

The least important is for-profit plans that are good at marketing but less good at funding needed patient care. I would force them to go non-profit AKA mutualization. But using political capital to fix this geeky problem should not be a priority. Similarly, capping the salaries of non-profit executives also sounds good to me but may also not be worth the angst.

Next least important is the problem where doctors tell their patients that the most expensive care option isn’t available to them. This is a basically political problem in the U.S. I’m not sure what to do about this. You cannot take away physicians’ freedom of speech. I think it is less of an issue where the payer is more integrated with the care organization, as with Kaiser Permanente in California, Hawaii, and the D.C. area, and perhaps also with the systems in Germany, Switzerland, and the Netherlands.

The most important problem is lack of good-enough universal coverage. This should be the immediate goal. Don’t make the 700,000 existing health insurer employees into no-holds-barred enemies of universal care. Instead get everyone now uninsured, or greatly underinsured, into the Affordable Care Act model. As for foreign models, yes, move towards the best that are a bit closer to what we are used to in the U.S., like the German system.

But what harm would there be in a public option? Perhaps I should say – no harm at all. Try it! But I think back to the start-up of the ACA, which had enough glitches so that Republicans could get votes promising to restore the old order. So – sure, you have to try a real public option because of need to keep the Democratic Party coalition whole. But start with demonstration projects.

Are you under the impression that “non-profit” means they don’t make any money? Oh, dear.

New York Non-Profit Hospitals Amass Billions in Revenue While Profiting from Programs Meant for the Poor

How Much Do Non-Profit Hospitals Make (By State)?

These are but 2 examples. I learned 30 years ago that there is nothing more profitable than a “non-profit” hospital. I hope you will spend some time educating yourself about this.

Sure, but this is what Part G is for. Part G covers the 20% deductible for traditional Medicare (aka Medi-Gap).

I prefer the government to say what insurance companies must cover as reasonable medical care, over the insurance companies themselves making these determinations. When insurance companies decide, it’s based purely on profit. They like to take their time, too. People die while waiting for authorizations on Advantage plans.

This perspective also explains why Obama couldn’t get the public option module when the ACA passed. It was the most important part of the legislation, because it was meant to provide meaningful competition to health insurance companies.

The public option was intended to force insurers to get real about their profits. No other entity besides government is leviathan enough to provide such competition. Now you know why insurers fought the public option so hard: It meant their profits were going to decrease.

Now that Obamacare has been around awhile and is popular, it may be possible to enact the public option module of the legislation. It will still be an uphill slog. Do expect to start hearing about “death panels” again. (Completely ignoring that this is exactly what health insurance companies offer when they deny you coverage. Again, based solely on profit.)

That’s why most people take out private insurance in the UK. Private hospitals also offer things like private rooms and better food, but they totally suck if there is an emergency.

I had private health at a hefty discount from my employer some years ago. I had some nasal polyps, and the NHS wait time was a year plus. When I told my GP I could go private, he picked up the phone, and we arranged an appointment with a consultant a few days later. The consultant, after examining me, offered a choice of dates for the op which did not involve a hospital stay.

Personally, I think this is the only way it can be changed in the US. Health insurance companies are too entrenched in our culture, and they’re not going to let go without keeping a good slice of the pie.

There is also the challenge of what to do with all the people who will be put out of work if we abruptly change the model. In addition to employees of the health insurance companies themselves, there are lots of “hangers-on” employees: Medical billings, coders, cafeteria plan administrators and so many more. This will be a decades-long transition. If it happens at all.

I don’t totally disagree with you here. In my post, I said I was for salary caps, although I didn’t mention hospitals.

Searching for the word compensation here, I see that the 2025 Bernie-Sanders-introduced Medicare for All bill does include compensation caps:

How low are they expected to be?

Do I think you could run an good Ivy League hospital with executives being paid no more than a Veterans Affairs heart surgeon? Yes. Is it plausible to immediately lower hospital executive salaries by 90 percent (or more in a high executive salary city like New York)? I’m not sure. There better be something in the bill to keep them from going for-profit (and maybe there is something that would, indirectly make it implausible – this is complicated).

I don’t advocate for what Sanders wants to do, Medicare for All. I have no problem with it philosophically, I just don’t think it’s possible with our current model. It may become possible down the road, but not a direct switch.

I also have no problem with significant compensation for actual medical providers, meaning doctors and other hands-on health care workers. Those people put in the time, energy and money to learn how to save lives. They should be at the top of the compensation chain, IMHO.

It’s the leeches like corporate shills and shareholders who take vast amounts of profit and do nothing to add to the value of health care that I think should be severely dinged in the compensation racket.

And yes, it’s complicated! Most Americans try to oversimplify, and they just end up misunderstanding the breadth and depth of the problem. Unfortunately, it makes them easy to manipulate, too.

When people say medicare is more cost effective than private insurance its usually due to a few reasons.

  • Medicare spends far less on administration. Medicare spends 1-2% of their budget on administration, while private insurance spends 15-20% since they all have different systems.
  • Medicare offers lower reimbursement rates to providers
  • Medicare can bulk negotiate prices better than private insurers

If you collect a million in premiums for medicare they only spend about 20k on administration. They pay the providers less and negotiate prices better.

The private insurance companies spend 150-200k on administration, they pay the providers more and can’t negotiate prices as well.

Nations which have multiple private insurance plans like switzerland or the netherlands have cheap health care and affordable health insurance. But their administrative spending is also extremely low compared to the US.

A large non-profit blue cross plan would still spend 15-20% of its income on administration while medicare would only spend 1-2%.

Its possible for private insurance to have low administrative costs, but it would likely take massive federal reform.

Medicare farms out preauthorization to private insurance, and then charges ruinous coinsurance to anyone who doesn’t have private insurance.

It is true that Medicare saves on salaries for people who negotiate payment rates. But if you cut all their Blue Cross revenue roughly in half by forcing the hospitals to take Medicare rates for everything, aren’t there going to massive hospital closings just when you need more medical care because, under Medicare for All, all the preauthorized care that used to be, rightly or wrongly, denied by insurance companies now has to be provided?

I’m not against reducing health care administration costs as part of a universal heath care bill. I’m just against giving unrealistic hopes.

Yes.

I’m for the transition.

The only way to make it sustainable is for each major step to be sufficiently popular that it isn’t destroyed at the next election. It is possible to throw darts at any proposal, and just because I may do it here is no reason to be against the whole difficult and essential project.