With Democrats winning the House and Senate and setting their sights on 2028, the discussion about how to implement universal healthcare has arisen once again.
I have been noticing a few different terms thrown about in these discussions. Interestingly, it seems like some people (perhaps the majority?) are using them interchangeably out of ignorance, others are very careful to make the distinction, and others seem to alternate between clearly defining a distinction and blurring it, depending on whether they want to disown someone for insufficient ideological purity or to claim someone as a supporter of their preferred policy.
For this thread, I’m less interested in debating the pros and cons of the different alternatives - I think that’s definitely worth a separate thread, but only after we can agree on definitions.
It seems to me that there is a clear distinction here, and I’ll define the relevant terms as I see them; I am curious to see if others agree with how I’ve laid these out.
Universal Healthcare - this is the umbrella term for any policy which will make it so that everyone has coverage for some sort of healthcare. This option has almost universal support among Democrats; I can’t think of a single official who opposes it.
Public Option - this is the least radical way to achieve universal healthcare. This keeps our current system with companies offering insurance, but either through Medicare or a novel system, the government will offer a public option (title drop) to those who don’t have healthcare through other means.
Single Payer - this is a system where we abolish the current system with private companies offering insurance. Instead the government is the only one that offers insurance. This is akin to the British IHS system, and is more extreme than what many European countries (Germany, France, etc) have.
Medicare For All (M4A) - This is a specific proposal championed by Bernie, AOC, and the other members of the Medicare For All Caucus which currently has 58 members. This proposal calls for a single payer system that (unlike the IHS or any other comparable European system) would also include dental and vision coverage. It would basically eliminate and replace the entire health insurance industry. It doesn’t outright ban supplemental insurance, but since M4A goes so much further than the IHS, there isn’t really any room left for supplemental insurance - basically just elective cosmetic surgery, private hospital rooms, and out of country treatments.
I think this distinction is important to make. For example, I recently saw someone post a video of Talarico talking about universal healthcare, and they captioned it “Talarico shifts to supporting M4A!”. But Talarico wasn’t shifting at all - he’s always supported universal healthcare through a public option - and in the video he was certainly not in favor of the M4A plan.