Using nukes is a f***ing stupid idea.

Nukes will just piss off the rest of the world, and harm the planet. The only way to take out these fanatic groups is to assasinate them with a sniper.

There is your solution. Leave the innocent alone.

I agree that using nuclear weapons is a very bad idea. i guess assassination would be a little better, but isn’t that illegal? Do laws apply during war? I feel most of the US is willing to do anything for some revenge, I think this will just lead into a viscious cycle of death and destruction. War is bad. Peace is good.
think peace,
JB

As an aside: I believe that the only purpose a nuclear weapon should ever serve, is to provide a system of nuclear deterence, and even if fired upon by a nuke, there is no reason to respond with another nuke.

And a nuke is legal?

The king is dead, long live the king.

They’re fanatics for a reason–killing one, or a dozen, or a hundred only created a vacuum soon filled by more fanatics.

To the OP, yes, using nukes is a f***ing stupid idea–the entire nation, race, or religion cannot possibly be guilty.

So, between those two extremes, what to do?

I think that’s the question of the hour.

-David

No nukes, just merciless military prosecution. Let the name Osama bin Laden be forever cursed upon the lips of Afghani people as the man who brought total destruction to their own country.

Using nukes will invite terrorist nuclear retaliation.

Assassination is illegal by Executive Order. Another Executive Order could countermand that easily.

No thanks.

I also have to chip in that nukes are a stupid idea.

This topic is already being discussed in another thead in this forum, so I’ll close this one. A nuclear solution to WTC bombing?

bibliophage
moderator GQ