Was Pakistan always a bad idea?

Very funny.

Well India didn’t train crazy Hindu terrorists in Pakistan, but India isn’t totally innocent. Kashmir has got to be the single biggest pressing issue between the two countries since partition, and if the Kashmiris had any vote in their own fate, they would be a part of Pakistan.

Most Pakistanis would wish that India gets off its high horse and stops trying to interfere in its neighbors internal affairs.

No, seriously: What threat to India could come from Afghanistan, if India bordered it, but could not with Pakistan as a buffer state? I’m sure the Indian government would be much more effective than the Pakistani government has been at putting down the Taliban in the Northwest Provinces.

No, just support for terrorists in general.

Just like it was so successful in Kashmir, Nagaland, Bodoland, Arunachal Pradesh or the entire Red Corridor

And what threat to India could come from Afghanistan. Yeah, lets see the last severalthousand years of history perhaps?

The current government is attempting to increase its influence in Afghanistan (the OP was complaining about it a while back) so apparently that is no longer the case.

Nevertheless, I think the Indian government would be more effective than the Pakistani government has been at putting down the Taliban, if only because the Indian government – unlike the Pakistani government – would not be in any way conflicted as to whether it really wants to put down the Taliban.

Absolute speculation on your part. The Pakistan Government has about 150,000 men active in the insurgency hit areas and suffered about 30,000 Civilian casualties and millions of people dislocated after the operation. If you genuinely believe that despite all this the government or the country as a whole does not want every last Talib dead you are insane.

And while we are at it the US seems even less interested in stopping the Taliban. As evidenced last year by the abandoning of posts on the Pak border before the Operation in South Waziristan.

Never mind.