Week 3 CFB -- Which AP Top 25 team(s) will lose?

Your basic reminder:

— Thursday, September 17

7:30 PM EDT ESPN
(11) Clemson @ Louisville

Here’s the final crosstable:



==========================================================================================================================================
                               %%%                       $$$          @@@        ###    $$$    %%%         ###  @@@ 
                              Bama  MichSt  USC  Geor  NotDam  FLSt  UCLA  Clem  LSU  GaTech  Miss  TX-AM  Aub  BYU  Utah  Missou  NoWstrn
                              ============================================================================================================
Apex Rogers                 4                          NotDam                                 Miss         Aub  BYU
Barkis is Willin'           5               USC                                       GaTech  Miss         Aub  BYU
basset hound                5                          NotDam                                 Miss         Aub  BYU                NoWstrn
BobLibDem                   7                                  FLSt                   GaTech  Miss  TX-AM  Aub  BYU        Missou  
dba Fred                    4                                        UCLA             GaTech  Miss         Aub
DinoR                       5 Bama                     NotDam              Clem                            Aub  BYU
excavating (for a mind)     5                                                    LSU  GaTech  Miss              BYU                NoWstrn
JohnT                       5       MichSt                                            GaTech  Miss         Aub  BYU  
Nauplius                    5                                                         GaTech  Miss         Aub  BYU                NoWstrn 
Oakminster                  4                          NotDam        UCLA                     Miss         Aub
Oredigger77                 4                          NotDam                                 Miss         Aub  BYU
RetroVertigo                4                          NotDam                                 Miss         Aub  BYU
Sauron                      4                          NotDam                                 Miss         Aub  BYU
txtumbleweed                5                          NotDam        UCLA                     Miss         Aub       Utah   
USCDiver                    6 Bama               Geor  NotDam                                              Aub  BYU                NoWstrn
Wolverine                   4                                                         GaTech  Miss         Aub  BYU  
yellowjacketcoder           5                          NotDam                                 Miss         Aub  BYU                NoWstrn
Zeldar                      5                                                    LSU  GaTech  Miss              BYU                NoWstrn
Zyanthia                    5 Bama                     NotDam                                              Aub  BYU  Utah
                              ============================================================================================================
                              Bama  MichSt  USC  Geor  NotDam  FLSt  UCLA  Clem  LSU  GaTech  Miss  TX-AM  Aub  BYU  Utah  Missou  NoWstrn
    19                     91   3     1      1     1     11      1     3     1    2      8     16     1     17   16    2      1       6   /91
============================================================================================================================================= 

Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 19

=====================================


Good luck to excavating (for a mind) tonight! :slight_smile:

My bad! I misread the crosstable thinking it was excavating (for a mind) who had picked Clemson to lose. It was actually DinoR who gets the -1 for that game. Sorry for both mistakes. :frowning:

He wasn’t too far from getting the point either. Maybe we should have a rule that if a ranked team wins but drops out of the top 25 for having such a crappy win you get the point anyway :smiley: (Not that I think Clemson will drop that far, but I don’t think they deserve to be as highly ranked as they are after that game)

Missed it by that much.

Not a bad point! Only real problem is having to wait a week to see the new AP Poll numbers. Other than that it would make for a fun wrinkle. Others may wish to chime in on it before we put it into effect – maybe next year?

I almost picked Missouri to lose. As weak as I thought they might be I didn’t think UCONN could do it. It would have been another missed it by that much.

I had been thinking that the win ugly and drop out change. I didn’t see it happening much if at all. Auburn dropped 12 by winning ugly against an FCS team. What are the odds of dropping out if it’s an FCS team? It would have to be a team already 20+. Even then 2/3 of P5 team’s schedules are against P5 teams in conference where the hit likely wouldn’t be bad for a win. How rare would that rule end up being?

Then Missouri stinks up the place as a #22. It might happen this week.

The scores:



==========================================================================================================================================
                               %%%                       $$$          @@@        ###    $$$    %%%         ###  @@@ 
                              Bama  MichSt  USC  Geor  NotDam  FLSt  UCLA  Clem  LSU  GaTech  Miss  TX-AM  Aub  BYU  Utah  Missou  NoWstrn
                              ============================================================================================================
Barkis is Willin'        +3/5                +1                                         +1     -1           +1   +1

Wolverine                +2/4                                                           +1     -1           +1   +1  

DinoR                    +1/5  +1                        -1                 -1                              +1   +1
JohnT                    +1/5         -1                                                +1     -1           +1   +1  
Nauplius                 +1/5                                                           +1     -1           +1   +1                   -1   
Zyanthia                 +1/5  +1                        -1                                                 +1   +1   -1 

Apex Rogers               0/4                            -1                                    -1           +1   +1
dba Fred                  0/4                                         -1                +1     -1           +1
Oredigger77               0/4                            -1                                    -1           +1   +1
RetroVertigo              0/4                            -1                                    -1           +1   +1
Sauron                    0/4                            -1                                    -1           +1   +1
USCDiver                  0/6  +1                 -1     -1                                                 +1   +1                   -1  

basset hound             -1/5                            -1                                    -1           +1   +1                   -1  
yellowjacketcoder        -1/5                            -1                                    -1           +1   +1                   -1  
Zeldar                   -1/5                                                     -1    +1     -1                +1                   -1  
excavating (for a mind)  -1/5                                                     -1    +1     -1                +1                   -1  
BobLibDem                -1/7                                   -1                      +1     -1     -1    +1   +1          -1    

Oakminster               -2/4                            -1           -1                       -1           +1

txtumbleweed             -3/5                            -1           -1                       -1           +1        -1    
                              ============================================================================================================
                              Bama  MichSt  USC  Geor  NotDam  FLSt  UCLA  Clem  LSU  GaTech  Miss  TX-AM  Aub  BYU  Utah  Missou  NoWstrn
    19                     91   3     1      1     1     11      1     3     1    2      8     16     1     17   16    2      1       6   /91
============================================================================================================================================= 

Multiple Choice Poll. Voters: 19


Scroll right for the complete crosstable

Congrats to Barkis is Willin’!

Here’s how things stand:



                       Total    Week 1   Week 2   Week 3 

RetroVertigo            +6/10     +3/3     +3/3      0/4  
Nauplius                +6/12     +1/3     +4/4     +1/5  
   
jsc1953                 +5/7      +2/4     +3/3  
Wolverine               +5/9      +2/2     +1/3     +2/4  

Barkis is Willin'       +4/9       0/1     +1/3     +3/5 

yellowjacketcoder       +3/13     +2/4     +2/4     -1/5                                                   
bump                    +2/4      +2/4       
dba Fred                +2/8               +2/4      0/4 
basset hound            +2/8      +3/3              -1/5   
Zyanthia                +2/12     +1/3      0/4     +1/5   
                      
Chingon                 +1/2      +1/2       
astorian                +1/3               +1/3  
BigAppleBucky           +1/5      +1/5   
DinoR                   +1/5                        +1/5   
txtumbleweed            +1/11     +3/3     +1/3     -3/5    
excavating (for a mind) +1/13     +1/5     +1/3     -1/5   
                                
hende                    0/1       0/1      
zoog                     0/2       0/2     
russian heel             0/3       0/3      
Jman                     0/3                0/3   
Apex Rogers              0/4                         0/4
Sauron                   0/4                         0/4
USCDiver                 0/6                         0/6 
Zeldar                   0/12     +2/4     -1/3     -1/5   
JohnT                    0/12      0/4     -1/3     +1/5   
 
Oredigger77             -1/11     -1/3      0/4      0/4   

justmeetee              -2/1      -2/1  
Oakminster              -2/10     +1/3     -1/3     -2/4 
         
Jackmannii              -3/1      -3/1    
Omar Little             -3/2               -3/2     
Death of Rats           -3/3      -3/3              
Some Call Me... Tim     -3/3      -3/3     
 
BobLibDem              -11/25     -9/9     -1/9     -1/7 

===========================  
Total              Voters: 33
Week 1                      Voters: 25
Week 2                               Voters: 18         
Week 3                                        Voters: 19

I’m surprised nobody else picked USC to lose. Stanford is better than they played against NW and they’ve had the Trojans’ number in recent years. That was a fun game to watch, both teams looked great on offense.