Weekly Comic Book Review Thread - 4/22/2004

So what’s everyone reading this week? I’ll have to add some more items when I get home, but at the top of my list is Superman/Batman #9, which shows us the girl who is apparently Kara Zor-El acclimating to life on Earth.

Two thumbs up on the art, and two thumbs up on the writing, to be brief.

Highlights include Batman - who I think is very well-written in this series, and :

[spoiler]Harbinger? Where the hell has SHE been?

Oh, and Batman 100% confident he can take down Artemis. As it should be.[/spoiler]

I didn’t buy any new issues this week, but I’ll throw my last week’s purchases into the thread:

JSA # 60: A bit of a disappointment. The good news is that we get to see Doctor Mid-Nite’s supporting staff, who were a lot of fun to read about in the mini-series that introduced the character. The bad news is that a) one of them is now dead, b) the writers are laying on Mister Terrific’s non-belief WAY too thick - granted, it probably serves a plot purpose in this Spectre-centered story arc, but we’ve heard too much about it before this that it’s getting annoying, and c) the writers are now using Doctor Mid-Nite as a proxy to re-hash (in a DCU context) hackneyed conspiracy theories about the U.S. government and inner-city drugs.

H-E-R-O # 15: It’s not easy to get me to start picking up a new comic, but this series hooked me with issue # 5. I’m a bit apprehensive about revisiting past characters of this series and about Robby Reed taking center stage, because it might weaken what I like best about this book - the fact that the H-E-R-O dial is used as a vehicle for personality exploration in general rather than as a device for a specific person to use. Nonetheless, the story is compelling and I certainly would not want the past ignored, so I’ll give this issue a thumbs up…we’ll see in the upcoming months if my apprehension is justified. The one down-side is the fact that Robby’s story, as told in this issue, outright contradicts the existing back-story of “Dial H for Hero,” the other participants of which have very much interacted with the rest of the DC Universe. I sincerely hope that there’s some explanation given for that rather than this being a blatant ret-con…again, something that I imagine we’ll find out in the next few months.

I consider myself a fairly jaded comic reader. The books that truly knock me on my @ss are few and far between. This week I found just such a graphic novel: Blood Song: A Silent Ballad.

I’d heard great things about it before, but feared it would be one of those oh-so-precious indy books adored by … a certain indie snob crowd that prides itself on approving of only the most inaccessible or deliberately ugly works. I couldn’t have been more wrong.

I don’t pretend to fully understand it after one read, but the haunting visuals exercise a demanding pull on the imagination that can’t be ignored or denied. On a simple narrative level, it’s the tale of a journey undertaken by a young woman and her wolf-like dog fleeing her village in the rain forest after it is invaded and despoiled by invading soldiers. After a long sea voyage, they wind up in an urban metropolis. On a metaphorical level … well, I won’t spoil the surprises. I suspect there are any number of ways to read it, depending on ones interests and preconceptions.

Not for everyone, but for those with a taste for unusual, beautiful, thought-provoking material, it would be difficult to top this one.

New X-men - the second part of the fallout of the events of Morrison’s run on the book. Terrible writing from Austen, and woefully unbelievable “chemistry” between Scott and Emma. Say wha? Between this and the absolute abortion that is Uncanny, I’m hoping this whole “X-books Relaunch” thing makes it worthwhile. At least they’re bringing Chris Claremont and Alan Davis back!

Runaways - Consistently the best Marvel book on shelves. Brian K. Vaughn should be juggling 14 books a month like Brian Michael Bendis; or maybe the fact that he isn’t is why Runaways and Y, The Last Man are so consistently great. Runaways is the only comic book I’ve ever read that actually captured believable and charmingly-bratty teen dialogue. Unlike the recent NYX, which showcased a morbidly-obese 40-year-old man’s idea of “what the kids talk like,” Runaways consistently nails it.

“Hey, you should read the new She-Hulk! It’s a hoot!”

Well, I mentioned in the other thread that I wanted to say it. Dan Slott…this is I think my first exposure to him, and I’m well pleased. I don’t know why but I’ve always loved She-Hulk, and so far this series isn’t a disappointment. Who knew comic books were legal documents in the MU? One problem I have though, I thought the main publisher in the MU was Marvels comics.

I doubt there’s any consistent consensus (try saying that five times fast) as to the major comic book publishers in the Marvel Universe.

Though I did recently read the Squadron Supreme TPB (Great read, by the way) … and we learn during Nighthawk’s brief trip to Marvel-Prime that Steve Rogers is currently drawing for Marvel Comics at the time.

Of course it stinks. It’s a Marvel Comic.

All Marvel Comics stink.

Although She-Hulk is a hoot. In fact, she’s 2 hoots. Biggun’s, too.

You know, while I may pick up some of the new X-stuff to see if I can force myself to get back into it, it wasn’t Grant Morrison that ran me off… it was Chris Claremont and Alan Davis. Before Morrison’s stuff started, there were a few issues where all previous character development and continuity were just chucked right out the window - and the blame lies at the feet of Claremont and Davis.

Davis was good on Excalibur, but I can’t think of much else he’s done that I’ve liked… and Claremont used to be good on Uncanny, but after seeing what he’s done to JLA in collaboration with John Byrne… ech.

Aw, come on. Exiles is pretty darn good. Captain Marvel is a good read. X-Statix is hit and miss. Ultimate Spidey is good, too. Supreme Power rocks.

In fact, Marvel’s got lots of good books… just none of their core titles is worth anything.

Leave It To Chance, vol 1 - I understand why author James Robinson loves this book so much (he prefers it to Starman). I’ve read individual issues, but it really is a complete story arc that should be read en toto. It’s Nancy Drew meets Harry Potter. With a friendly pet dragon named St. George. What’s not to love about this book?

Epileptic vol 1. - This is one of those very good books that I appreciate, but can’t say I “enjoy” per se. Artistic French boy grows up in family with autistic brother, and parents seek all sorts of freaky “alternative” methods to cure him. Depressing, but artistically cool.

The Spirit Archives, vol 1. - No doubt in my mind that it’s every bit as artistically ground-breaking and influential as everyone says it is, and in most respects it aged better than it had any right to. However, the portrayals of black people alone are enough to send me screaming. At least I tried.

Blankets - Autobiography about the religious and sexual coming of age of a sensitive young Christian boy. And the atheist declares it to be good. Very good. But for my personal library, I’ll stick to Chance and the dragon, thank you very much.

Eagle, the making of an Asian-American President - This series (at least so far) is almost as good as the hype has made it out to be. Sadly, my library purchased only volumes 1, 3, and 4 of this five volume series. (No, the other books weren’t checked out - I verified that.) An excellent story that I feel is let down a little by the art. Although the style isn’t completely stereotypical manga, everyone’s eyes are a bit Disneyfied, which undercuts the serious story. And, as much as I hate to complain about this point …

Shouldn’t a series subtitled “The Making of an Asian-American President”, about the campaign of a character we’re told repeatedly looks Japanese look, well, at least vaguely Asian? He doesn’t. The other Asian characters do, but he looks more Causcasian than his Caucasian opponent. Strange.

Orbiter. I didn’t expect to like this as much as I did. One of Ellis’ better recent works, despite omitting the third act.

House on the Borderland. Hands-down one of the strangest books I’ve read in ages, and that’s a compliment. Take one part Bram Stoker’s paranoia about the sexual awakening of women, one part Lovecraft purple prose, a pair of odd siblings. Add in an English country house haunted by demonic pig things, a dash of good old-fashioned canine heroism, and a whiff of repressed incestuous longings. Stir vigorously. Perhaps it’s appropriate that this Vertigo offering seems to be obscure and hard to locate. For the horror fans among us, it’s well worth a read (although preferably not at its $30 cover price). Good enough to make me seek out the source material.

The Shadow: Blood and Judgment TPB

This four-issue miniseries came out from DC in the mid-to-late 1980s, with writing AND art by Howard Chaykin, who I love from American Flagg!. It was one of DC’s earliest “mature readers” titles, which were all collected under the Vertigo imprint around 1992 or '93. Blood and Judgment was later collected in a TPB that is currently out of print, but I scored this one on eBay.

I was expecting a nice, gritty, sexy Shadow story set in the '30s, a la American Century, but Chaykin set this one in present day (the '80s). Someone is murdering the Shadow’s old allies and agents, and the Shadow himself makes a dramatic return on the last page of the first issue, having not aged a single day since his disappearance 35 years prior. The second issue is the standout, explaining the Shadow’s convoluted origin and multiple identities, and also where he’s been for so long and why he doesn’t look a day older. Hint: both of those have to do with “the technologically-advanced mythical city of Shambala.” After that, he establishes a new network of agents, takes on a VERY old enemy, and saves New York from a nuclear disaster. Fear not, there is just enough sordid sex and misogyny (Chaykin trademarks) to garner the “mature readers” warning.

This miniseries led directly up to the ongoing Shadow series written by Andy Helfer and drawn by Bill Sienkiewicz (and later Kyle Baker). I have read most of these comics in order, and they make a lot more sense now with Chaykin’s story before them. The Helfer issues were full of violent mayhem and dark comedy at the same time–perfect Vertigo fare. They focused more on the Shadow’s wacky agents than the man himself, including two characters Todd McFarlane TOTALLY ripped off when he created Sam and Twitch. Read the issues and you’ll have no doubt of this.

Conde Nast Publications owns The Shadow, and they revoked their license from DC after reading the Helfer/Baker series, including a story where the Shadow’s sons accidentally cut his head off and reattached it to a robot body. They didn’t like their character being treated that way, I guess. After DC tried a more traditional series set in the '30s and '40s, The Shadow Strikes! by writer Gerard Jones, Conde Nast took their toy with them and went home. I believe Dark Horse was the last to publish a Shadow comic, probably around 1994, when the Alec Baldwin movie came out.

I guess I like the IDEA of The Shadow more than any of the actual recent comics. A vigilante who wore a black fedora and trench coat, scared criminals with a creepy laugh, “clouded men’s minds” with hypnosis, kept a vast network of loyal undercover agents, disguised himself with multiple secret identities, and dispensed blazing justice with twin .45s is a cool idea, even cooler when you think about how his pulp novels and radio show predated Batman and almost every comic book superhero. But in the end, the Helfer/Sienkiewicz/Baker comics left me pretty cold, and this Chaykin series that immediately preceded them didn’t knock my socks off either. The art was good enough (with that super-bright '80s-style coloring) and Chaykin’s layouts were of course excellent. But I wouldn’t recommend people go out and spend big bucks on this out-of-print TPB. I paid around $6 for it and I’m not disappointed in that, but I was expecting “American Century-meets-Sandman Mystery Theatre,” and my enthusiasm was quickly dashed.

Cable & Deadpool #1

I really enjoyed Cable & Deadpool #1, much more than any of the other “nostalgia” books I’ve sampled over the past few years: G.I. Joe by Devil’s Due, Transformers by Dreamwave, and even more than Formerly Known As the Justice League.

The plot seems simple enough: Deadpool is hired by a cult to retrieve some McGuffin-like object, and Cable shows up there too. They don’t even meet until the final page, but you know the hijinx are about to ensue. Fabian Nicieza has a very good handle on writing Deadpool–definitely a wacky, funny guy, but also someone who can kick ass when he needs to. I never read Joe Kelly’s famous run, but Fabian co-created him and wrote that first miniseries, so I think Deadpool will be in good hands.

As for Cable, he seems to have matured a lot since the early issues of his own series, which was the last time I paid attention. He’s dropped the giant shoulder pads and picked up telepathy and telekinesis, and seems to be out to find peaceful solutions to problems, rather than running in with abnormally large guns a-blazing. I’m sure he will play the straight man to Deadpool’s dark comedian in the relationship.

Mark Brooks’ art is beautiful, made even better by the amazing coloring. It’s a shame he’s leaving after only two issues. The cover is by Rob Liefeld, and while he draws the characters the same way he did back in 1991, readers shouldn’t panic–these are the modern versions of Cable and Deadpool in the comic; they haven’t regressed back to the Liefeld X-Force days. Still, Liefeld’s art is a guilty pleasure for me. I truly feel bad for the guy for the horrendous reputation he has now, although to his credit, he has gotten better. I was pleased to note this first issue was sold out at the first shop I went to, and the buzz is good so far. Marvel has already announced an X-Force miniseries in the works, written by Nicieza with Liefeld handling ALL the art chores, but I’ll believe that when I see it. I guess '80s nostalgia is over, and now is the time for early '90s nostalgia. I wonder… do my plaid Skidz pants still fit?

Wildcats series 2, issues 8-28 (Joe Casey’s entire run, with art by Sean Phillips and Steve Dillon).

These grew on me, and I like them more now than after I first read them. The generic team of X-Men ripoffs you remember from the early days of Image Comics is gone. Casey (following in the footsteps of James Robinson and Alan Moore) has turned Wildcats into a thinking person’s superhero comic, with very few costumes, powers, and fights. So what good is that, you ask? This is new. This is the future.

While teams like the Authority spew catch-phrases about creating a “finer world,” Jack Marlowe, the Wildcat formerly known as Spartan, finally has a plan to do something about it that doesn’t involve mass murder and major collateral damage. The days of slugfests with the villain-of-the-week are over. Marlowe will use the HALO Corporation and a mysterious energy source to truly make the world a better place. While some of the events in these comics were disturbing and could be interpreted as misogynistic, I really like the direction Joe Casey took the remaining characters in. Now I’m ready to pick up the TPBs of Wildcats series 3.0!

By the way, #8-28 are reprinted in three TPBs, Vicious Circles, Serial Boxes, and Battery Park, but I bought all 21 of the singles because together, they only came out to about $15. Major bargain! (And I heard #1-7, by writer Scott Lobdell, are totally skippable.)

You mean you don’t like Powers? :slight_smile:

Really Bendis can do little wrong. And I hate to say that. I almost wish he WOULD blow it sometime, but everyone of the 355 books he writes that I’ve glommed have been really good. Powers, Ultimate Spider-Man, Ultimate X-Men, The Pulse, Alias…I don’t know how he does it. He’s as prolific as VC Andrews, Franklin W Dixon, and R.L Stein combined.

Comics I Bought This Week :

Books of Magic TPBs #6 and #7 - Old news, but good stuff.

Wonder Woman #203 - I’m not a regular reader of WW, and I took this (Batman-guest-starring) opportunity to see what the Amazon Princess was up to … and I’m a bit lost. Themyscira is off the U.S. East Coast? Who knew? Art’s pretty good… sort of reminds me of Dodson’s work … and Greg Rucka, apparently, can write.

Captain Marvel #22 - It’s too bad they’re cancelling this title, because it is supremely funny. Looking at the credits, I can see that’s because it’s Peter David. The man’s like a comedic-comic god.

Cable and Deadpool #2 - Deadpool is one of my favorite Marvel characters, I don’t care what anyone says… and watching Cable use his TK to blow up DP’s head, knowing that he’ll just get back up again, is morbidly humorous.

Outsiders #11 - Great book. Arsenal tries to recover psychologically from taking a hail of bullets to the chest … there’s some great-fun dialogue between he and Nightwing this issue.

Tom Strong’s Terrific Tales #10 - I won’t lie. I read this book because of Art Adams’s Jonni Future. I love the man’s artwork. The title’s a little light on story, but that’s because it’s cramming in three different tales… two of them are serial-style and have been going on for a while.

Stryke Force #1 - All the generic hoopla we’ve come to expect and love from Image, but I won’t give up on it yet. Artwork’s got some potential.

  • I know these are short ‘n’ sweet, but I’ll be happy to go into m ore detail about any specific title anyone’s interested in.

A local comic shop was having a killer sale and I picked up almost $300 of TPB’s and graphic novels for under $150. So all my reviews are of collections as opposed to single issues.

The Spirit Archives, Vol. 5
Just got done reading it in the last hour. It was pretty good, but I was disappointed that none of the artwork was done by Eisner. It’s a bunch of the stories that were done when he was serving in WWII. Still, it’s got artwork by Lou Fine and that’s nothing to sneer at. The stories are pretty weak, with each eight page story involving The Spirit figuring out a mystery often with no clues whatsoever, he just shows up in the right place at the right time. There was one story I enjoyed though, and it was about a group of Nazi’s invading Central City and was basically a big ad to buy war bonds. Really only interesting from an historical perspective, being an American propaganda piece and all, and amusing because they got the Swastikas backwards.

Selkie, I agree with your distaste regarding Eisner having a minstrel type character in the book, but you might be interested in his view on the topic. Here’s an interview with Eisner. His opinion on Ebony and the reactions he’s gotten regarding him can be found about three-quarters of the way down the page. You also might want to try the later volumes in the Spirit series because he seems to drop Ebony entirely. I’m assuming this because I have The Spirit Casebook Vol. 2 which is comprised of later Spirit stories and I don’t recall Ebony being anywhere in them.

Promethea, Book 2
Y’know, I love the premise of this series, a fictional character brought to life by those who add to her story combined with a heavy dose of mysticism. The concept that all fictional worlds exist together, and that to some extent they exist in the real world is fascinating, but Book 2 was boring as hell (these topics are also being done in Warren Ellis’s Planetary, only better and in a much different fashion). I know Moore has gotten interested in witchcraft over the years, but there are parts of this book that read like a primer in these beliefs and tend to overshadow the other issues he’s trying to explore. While the topic of magic might be interesting all by itself the way it is presented in this book is dull; Moore just goes through a point by point description of these beliefs and it is very dry reading. I didn’t finish the last issue in the book because I was bored to tears. I’m going to go back and try to read it again because I truly enjoyed the first book and have already picked up the third so I’m committed that far. But if book three doesn’t pick up the pace I’m going to drop Promethea from my reading list.

The Punisher: Welcome Back, Frank
God, this series kicked ass. No moral dilemmas (except for the DD sequence), balls to the wall action with no stopping to consider the ethical or real life consequences. Turn off your brain and have fun. I’m surprised I enjoyed this book as much as I did because I’ve never been a big fan of the Punisher, but Ennis and Dillon produced a top-notch book. My only beef is that while in the introduction Ennis pleads with the reader to set aside ethical considerations and just read the book for what it is he sets up a moral dilemma involving Daredevil and the Punisher’s actions:

[spoiler]The Punisher is on a rooftop and is going to shoot a gangster with a sniper rifle when DD gets the drop on him. The Punisher, expecting DD, has set up some sonic weapon nearby to mess up DD’s senses, and the Punisher then proceeds to tie him up, tape a pistol to his hand and give DD a choice. DD can either shoot the Punisher in the head (supposedly he can’t do it anywhere else due to the Punisher wearing body armor) or DD can stand by and let the Punisher kill someone in cold blood. DD takes the hard choice and aims for Punisher’s head, only to discover that the Punisher has taken the firing pin out of the gun.

My problems with this sequence are legion. First of all, it seems like every other issue one of Daredevil’s enemies has come up with some way to throw off his senses, so he’s used to that tactic and it seems more in character for him to overcome Frank’s ultrasound weapon and take him down, as opposed to folding like a card table.

Secondly, DD would’ve known from the Punisher’s heartbeat that the Punisher was lying about DD being able to shoot him. He would’ve known something was wrong with the gun and known he was helpless to stop the Punisher.

Thirdly, DD ain’t a stupid person, so even though he missed the Punisher lying it should’ve occurred to him that all he had to do was shoot the Punisher in the shoulder right as he fired so as to throw off his aim (body armor can’t completely negate the force of the impact. DD could hear/sense when the Punisher was going to pull the trigger and could’ve timed his shot to it. No need for a head shot.

Finally, even if we ignore all of the above, there is no moral equivalency between killing someone in cold blood and killing someone as a last resort to prevent them from killing in cold blood. Ennis must’ve had one too many pints the day he wrote that issue.

All in all a crappy sequence and a poor treatment of a respected character.[/spoiler]
However, except for the above the book is basically a roller coaster: exciting, satisfying and shallow. Welcome Back, Frank was great read overall, just don’t go in expecting Shakespeare.

Road to Perdition
This was a fun book. A combination of gangster stories and Lone Wolf and Cub set in the days when women were women and men wore hats, the story is about a hitman whose loving family is killed by the mob he works for causing him to set out for payback with his son in tow. A good twist on the typical revenge story. The artwork is passable IMO, it’s good but not outstanding, and the story is basically set as a documentary with one character doing the narration with little actual commentary on the action leaving judgments up to the reader. I don’t want to say I was disappointed by the book as it was pretty much everything I expected, but I will say that the book, while enjoyable, didn’t seem especially memorable. If you’ve seen the movie you still might want to read this book as there are noticeable differences between the two (e.g. Jude Law’s character is absent in the graphic novel).

There’s more stuff I’ve read in the past week, but I figure this post is long enough and I’ll just leave it at the four reviews above.

ACK! SO LUCKY! I wish any of our local comic shops had a sale once in a while, or just that they didn’t suck. Marking up back issues and even TPBs ensures they never move any old stock, and customers take fewer risks on books. I’d buy a ton of TPBs if I could even get a slight discount below cover price.

Blacksad

Unbelievably cool art.

Film Noir in comics form.

Sure, Anthro, but the best art since Wendi Pini put Spock ears on a midget. :smiley:

Go HERE.

Not all graphic novels available, but those that are are 38% off. $100 orders ship free!

So, sell to your comics store.

I found it once at my local library and LOVED it!

To think I had hesitated for just a moment to plunk down for a paid subscription to this place … what was I thinking?!

Asylum:

Thanks for the heads-up about the Ebony character (and the interview, which I plan to read later). My amazingly well-stocked library has, I believe, a full set of the Spirit Archives. I’ll try one of the later ones and see if it’s more to my taste. The Spirit is one of those things I feel duty bound to read.

Promethea, book 2 - If those are the issues I think they are, which some have dubbed “Alan Moore’s Magical Mystery Tour”, I’m sorry to say it doesn’t get a whole lot better. Like you, I really enjoyed the first volume, but I thought the story fell apart shortly thereafter. Remains absolutely beautiful to look at throughout.

Road to Perdition - I liked the art on this, but I know I’m in the minority. I almost wish I hadn’t seen the film first, because I think this is one of the very rare occasions where the film is better than the book. Somehow the book doesn’t have the same sense of weight and importance that the movie did.

Bosda Di’Chi of Tricor, thanks for making a noir junkie’s day. Don’t know how that one has slipped past my radar, but it’s an omission that I will rectify soon.

Xander_Cane - Finally, someone else who has read this GN! There have been times I’ve wondered if I hallucinated it. I really wonder at the implied slap at its quality in the forward, given that the entire forward never once mentions the book itself, only the source material.

CandidGamera - I recently discovered the Books of Magic via the library, and immediately rushed out to buy the whole series, including the uncollected material, via eBay. Did I read it too quickly in my eagerness, or does volume seven Death After Death, make very little sense?

Actually the owner of the shop has this sale twice a year. All TPBs and GNs are half price, back issues 70% off and I don’t remember what else. I have no idea how he makes money off of this, and it’s not done to move stock because they stock up for the sales. Only thing I can figure is that it’s a publicity deal. The guy who owns the shop is the same one who organizes the Baltimore Comic-con every year, and that suckers gotten big.

I’ll tell you what, the next one is around Halloween or Thanksgiving, I don’t remember which but I should get a postcard about it, so if you drop me a line to remind me and promise to pay me back I’ll pick up some stuff for you and send it to you. FTR, I’m known by board members in real life and several of them have my address and phone number, so I’m not a stalker. :slight_smile: