[QUOTE=DanBlather]
What’s the straight dope? Should I alternate days exercising specific muscles or just keep with my daily regimen?
[/QUOTE]
I’m not sure that anyone yet knows the definitive straight dope on this. I’ve been involved in self-training for at least 20 years, and every five years I notice that the rules change!
What follows is my own observations plus what reading I’ve done on the subject:
If you do weight training “to failure”, then you’ll probably feel a bit sore within several hours of each workout, and perhaps more so the first few times. If this describes you, then you may get better results by working the particular muscle every other day.
More and more evidence suggests that amateur athletes with a lot of willpower end up overtraining, resulting in diminished results and injury.
I have found that it makes sense to start out slower than you’d like, with less volume than you want, and fewer times per week than you’re motivated to do. It takes a good deal of time to get your body ready for a high-activity lifestyle, but if you take your time, you can do it.
Keep in mind that your body recovers more slowly as you age.
Remember the coach’s saying: You don’t get stronger when you’re working out, you get stronger when you’re recovering.
This suggests that a volume of maybe 45 minutes of below-threshold cardiovascular workout and 30 minutes of strength training every other day is plenty to start out with. If you feel like doing more, sit in a relaxing warm bath until the feeling goes away.
I have a running coach who is constantly cautioning me about this. Whenever I feel strong during a run, he tells me to ignore it. He believes that the foolproof measure of training capacity is resting heart rate. Take your heart rate immediately when you wake. In fact, try to stay lying down while you do it! Then monitor it on a regular basis. If it gets more than 10 bpm above “normal”, you’re overtraining.