Weird to attend son's PhD dissertation defense?

CairoSon is about to defend his PhD dissertation in physics, which is great - his parents are proud and happy. Since it’s going to be Thanksgiving week anyway, we’re planning to visit him and when the defense is over we’ll go to dinner -hopefully to celebrate, although if it’s not accepted, we’ll be there to commiserate and comfort.

I guess you can have people in the room when you do your defense? I wouldn’t know, I never got a PhD. CairoSon’s dad does have a doctorate, but no one attended his defense, and anyway it was years ago in a different field.

Personally, I think it seems way too helicopter-parenting to actually be in the room while he delivers his defense. Good grief, he’s 28!!! He hasn’t lived at home, or been financially supported by his parents, since he was 21. I must admit, there are times when he doesn’t seem very grown up to me, but that’s because I’m his mom. Objectively speaking, he is an adult who can and should be able to do things without mom and dad hovering. And it’s not like the topic of his defense is anything we would understand - it’s way too esoteric and complicated for that.

Anyway, I guess he does want us there in the room with him. Which is sweet, maybe?

I’m happy to be there if it helps him and if it’s not dysfunctional behavior, but it feels like it might be the latter. Would it be weird to go? I’m interested in what other people think.

That sounds extraordinarily weird to me. The only people in the room when I did it were the examiners.

I mean, anybody may present any number of lectures, seminars, colloquia, posters, disquisitions, etc., which anyone may attend, but walking into a thesis defense, oral examination, or viva voce unless you are involved?

If you want to be helpful, you could help him prepare by throwing good questions at him in a mock defense/examination.

Did he actually ask you to be there ?
Are you sure he doesn’t just think you want to be there with him ?

Hmmm…Master thesis defenses in the biology department were generally open when I was attending school. They would be publicly posted with a date time and room number in the hallways for everyone to see. I went to a number of them because I was a professional student hanging around the department for over a decade. Even asked a few questions now and then because I was genuinely curious. Professors would even solicit students (or certain students, anyway) and unrelated professors to attend. Well-attended defenses that packed the room were somehow considered a plus. I think the general idea was that it was considered good practice for the grad students to have to respond to public questions.

However note that this was a state school that granted very few doctorates. So I have no experience with those.

I am 100% sure that traditions vary. If it is a publicly announced presentation, then you would be expected to answer questions or comments from any attendees.

This reminds me of parents wanting to be present for their kid’s workplace performance review, which I’ve found bizarre.

Ask him!

It varies by subject and university what the rules are. I’ve attended a bunch in the last few years, actually from multiple universities.

In many there’s a public component, to which it’s 100% normal to invite friends and family, then it moves to a private room with just the examiners. In some, this public talk is an hour long plus questions and a good part of the grilling will take place during the questions by the audience, which will include senior staff. In others the talk is shorter, less formal and audience questions may be a minor component or even non existent.

Some don’t have the public component, but even then some people invite friends and family to be around for the end bit to celebrate.

Most of the ones I’ve attended with a public talk have had parents join, normally online, but a few in person. Not odd at all.

I only know a few people with adult kids that I know have PhDs. Some attended their kid’s defense and enjoyed being there for the mostly incomprehensible experience. Including defenses of hard science PhDs. Most did not attend.

So not an unheard-of idea, but well short of commonplace.

If I was looking at this decision w my own kid I’d mostly be concerned about what’s the norm in that department at that school. Once I know what that local norm is, and how strict / wide open the place is about norm compliance, I can make an informed decision with the kid’s best interest in mind.

The only people in the room when I had my PhD defense in physics were the examiners. I would’ve fely pretty weird with anyone else there, especially my parents.

Heck, my mother accompanied me once on a visit to a research lab (long story) and it made me feel weird, as if she was supervising me and making sure I didn’t break any of the apparatus

I came here to say this too, and that it’s not just inappropriate, but I would never permit any parent to sit in on any performance review I was conducting.

However, for a Ph.D. defense at your son’s institution, maybe it is acceptable. If you’re considering this then first have your son check with his department head. If it is permitted then you may additionally want to check with the department as well.

In either way you don’t want to negatively impact the outcome of his defense.

PhD defences are public, and it’s not weird for family to attend. It’s not usual, but not rare either at my institution.

Two question for the people who are suggesting that this would be like a parent attending a performance review:

Do you think CairoCarol’s son has reached this point without knowing the rules and norms at his own institution?

Do you think the university would allow a parent to attend a part of the examination that should be private and negatively impact the outcome?

He’s almost certainly just inviting his parents to a public talk he’s giving as part of the viva. This is a totally normal thing to do- especially if they’re there visiting anyway- and there is no chance it’s going to impact the outcome. I’ve been invited to people’s vivas because I met them once at a conference, a friend’s parents and brother flew over from Spain to attend a friend’s one even though her parents actually spoke no English and certainly didn’t understand the science. They’re public.

Incidentally, between my first post and this one, I was actually sent the link to my own public viva presentation, which will be in a couple of weeks. I have also been told I can invite people in person. Anyone wanna come? :wink:

I, and others in my friend group, traveled to Ann Arbor to attend this event for the one of us who earned a PhD. So it happens.

This is so highly dependent on the school, field of study and the personal feelings of the student that it’s impossible to answer but I can add anecdotal information from my experience.

I hope that this thread doesn’t get filled with wild guesses from people with zero experience in graduate school academia because obviously that would be useless. This is not like a performance review in any respect for example.

Firstly, phd defenses almost never fail. The student’s advisor would never allow it to happen if there was a chance of that.

More important than anything, what does the kid want? Did you ask? I stopped at a master’s which had an oral exam but I wouldn’t want my parents within ten miles of my presentation. If he doesn’t want you there, who cares what the norm is.

Where I went to school and where friends of mine recently went to school, phd defenses were public. It wouldn’t generally be weird for people to show up. Earlier this year I watched my friend’s defense on Zoom.

I can’t over emphasize this. What does he want?

As others have said, it really will depend on local tradition. Your son and his advisor should know.

When I did mine last century, dissertation defenses were technically open events, but it was extremely rare for outsiders to attend. It has completely flipped, and now it is very common for other graduate students, friends, partners, and family to all attend a defense, both in-person and remotely.

That was my wife’s experience too - examiners only (plus her academic adviser as observer).

So the answer is (again) that “normal practice” varies by school and program, but if outside observers are allowed, ask your son what he wants you to do. I can understand why you’d want to watch, and I can understand why he might not want you there, so go with his direction.

Even if it is allowed, I don’t think I would want anyone there. My search indicated that some institutions have public sessions with the date and time posted. I’m wondering if the candidate can request a private one instead. My search didn’t find anything indicating if the candidate had that choice.

If it’s allowed by the institution, I don’t find it weird at all. If you’ve been following your son’s career and have even a passing knowledge of physics, it won’t be completely Greek to you; I say go - it will be an enjoyable experience.

To add to the anecdote, I flew to Philadelphia just to attend a friend’s PhD defense. She was very happy to have her friends/family who supported her doctoral journey over the years in attendance.

Also to add - if his advisor is in any way competent, the defense will be pretty much a formality at this point. It is extremely rare that a PhD defense in physics is rejected. Advisors and committees usually do not schedule a final defense until they believe the research and dissertation meet program standards. Any research gaps or problems should have been brought up and resolved during numerous progress reviews.

In addition, at least in my experience, the committee is your advisor and a couple of handpicked professors so the adversaries are very friendly.