I though Alda/Vinnick scored some important victories, but on peripheral topics. His answer to debt relief was articulate, moving, and well-developed, for example, and he was refreshingly honest about education (though Smits/Santos was right–A/V was more about what’s wrong w/education than articulating, beyond vouchers, what he’d do).
But too often, on the topics this (liberal) hypothetical voter would be most interested in, he fell back too easily on Big Bureaucracy/Free Market. S/S had a very provocative response to health care but Vinnick had nothing to retort (and that’s a Free Market issue as much as any). Although his answer to ANWR was better than any I’ve heard from a real-life ®, he had nothing to contribute on alternate energy sources. He also had nothing but the tired generalities when Forrest tried to pin him on specific spending cuts.
That’s not too say S/S didn’t rely on some talking points too, and some of the positions from both were familiar without framing them in new contexts.
But A/V definitely had a better closing speech. He framed the “oppostion” of the two sides in a way that was accessible. I think the S/S closer was, within the context of the show, essential because this is a candidate few people know and it was as much about introducing himself as defining the qualities of their differences. A/V also seemed much more natural.
It reminded me a bit of the Reagan/Mondale debates, where Mondale would (IMHO) bloody Reagan on the details and facts and nuances, but the Gip would come across better–more natural, better sound bytes, broader vision. S/S was still a bit too stiff, since he still, in some sense, needed to earn his street cred in the political theater on a national scale, while A/V clearly came across as if he has nothing to prove. That confidence puts him over the top, I think, so that even though I agree with more (but not all) of what S/S was about, I have to give the debate to Vinnick (and kudos to Alda for doing an exemplary job).
I have to say, last night was the first night I was genuinely intrigued by the idea of A/V winning and seeing WW heading in a new direction. But based on the on-line polling, I don’t think there’s any hope of that actually happening (unless they want to kill the series).