Another vote for centipedes and millipedes. Having that many legs Should Not Be Allowed.
Nah. This is how you can tell when his feelings are hurt.
See? Evil!!!
Those deep sea fish with the luminous appendages and giant teeth? They are creatures straight out of hell. I saw a documentary on them when I was a kid and had nightmares for a week.
Among more common animals, Canadian geese oog me out. They hang out in packs, honk at you, poop all over, and I know they want to bite you. I can see them looking at me waiting to bite me. They are evil.
Wow, you hotlinked that. That * is* evil. 
It’s nice to see that Sam is still scaring people posthumously. *Actually * posthumously, I mean. As opposed to just seemingly posthumously.
I just remembered. I think the ocean sunfish is also pretty creepy.
I saw this documentary where they showed this frog or toad that somehow lays its eggs on its back. Under the skin! When the babies are ready, these big holes somehow open up and they come squirming out. Icky! Icky! Icky! I can’t even Google the little bastards to show you, they creep me out so bad. I think they live in South America. Makes me want to stay away from the entire continent.
Meh! I’ve been bitten by Canada (not Canadian, pardon the nitpick) geese lots of times. It’s like two pieces of smooth lightweight plastic coming together. Not painful in the least.
Watch out for those big white domestic geese though. They have teeth like hacksaws!
I have a serious dog phobia. It’s not so bad now, but 18 years or so ago, walking to the bus stop, I found myself on more than one occasion walking in the street in busy traffic rather than walk on a sidewalk by a house where I knew therew as a dog chained up. Being run over by a truck was fun, but the dog had me terrified.
I always thought that most monkeys and apes were cute, until I took a class involving them and saw a picture of one of these things. Truly horrifying!
My professor even thought they were creepy.
I was sitting in my basement and I heard my cat coming down the stairs so I went over to greet him,when i got there it wasnt my cat…it was a damn spider walking down my stairs,not terrible creeped out by spiders generally but this fugger did the trick.
I second leeches, just something about a slug/wormlike thing that drinks blood just creeps me out, and they’re so stretchy
the one time i ever had a leech on me, it paid for it with it’s slimy little life, after i pulled it off me (big no-no, the wound continues to bleed thanks to the leech’s anticoagulant saliva), i put it in a bottle of water and took it up to the house…
even as a child i had a very scientific mindset, focused sunlight from a magnifying lens wasn’t working that well, then i realized… leeches hate salt…
the water in it’s jar quickly became SALT water…
stupid parasite didn’t like that very much
since then i’ve never had another leech on me
i used to be terrified of ticks, now i’m just desensitized to them, used to fear even touching them, now i pull them off the family dog and cats like it’s no big deal, take them outside and proceed to cook them with the flame from my 2500-degree pressurized butane lighter
i’d never think of hurting animals, i hate people who hurt animals, but PARASITES are a different story, parasites have no redeeming traits, spiders eat undesirable insects, so they’re cool, but leeches and ticks serve no purpose, other than to spread disease
two whole pages and nobody’s creeped out by scorpians? Those things creep the shit out of me…I can’t even watch them behind glass. I’m fine with pretty much every other animal in existance though
I don’t like snakes, but the animal that creeps me out–BAD-is the Kimodo dragon.
I hate the way it lumbers along, it looks evil.
And I dont’ like iguanas, either. Those long what are they, fingers? Claws? Ugh.
Jesus Tap-Dancing Christ, how big was that thing?!
That makes the final line from that site especially creepy:
Descendant? Heh.
Sailboat
I am casting my vote for birds. All birds are creepy as fuck. They swoop from above and their ultimate goal is to eat your eyes, I swear! The other day a crow that had molted from the neck up stood outside my driver side door of my car and jumped back and forth and wouldn’t let me out. I was so creeped out and I wanted to cry because I could tell it was plotting my death. I didn’t though, I just cracked the window and threw a fry so it would chase it and go away.
Tikki, I opened this thread just so I could post about those icky toads (?) too!
Cats, monkeys, snakes? I mean, come on people! They ain’t got nothing on this thing. *The squirming toad babies come popping out of the skin on the big toad’s back! * That’s hard to top on the disgustingometer.
I saw a drawing of the thing in an encyclopedia when I was a little kid and never, ever forgot it. How you gonna forget something like that?
Jellyfish. Man, I can’t stand jellyfish. I’ve never actually seen one in person, but I find the idea of them to be so utterly repugnant that - gah! I’m actually not all that keen on beaches, in part, because I’m afraid of the little stinging snot-bags.
Come to think of it, I really don’t like any fish. (Yes, I know jellyfish aren’t really fish - but still.) Even the best of them are just giant bugs. With fins. And gills. That swim. None of which makes them any more endearing. I don’t even like seafood.