Just make sure it’s not doody.
Candy canes too.
What could I identify with my hand in a bag in a dark room? Most of them. I was alive when people saw films in theaters and sneaking in all the candy was expected.
Life Savers
Not sure if it’s known at all outside of the UK, but Edinburgh Castle Rock, from its unique crumbly and gritty texture.
j
Cotton candy
Pretty sure I could identify an Idaho Spud by feel alone.
Buttons. Nothing like eating a little paper with your candy!
Pez. Definitely Pez.
Twizzlers.
But don’t wipe your hand on your black pants after identifying it…
(they’re dusted with finely powdered sugar to keep them from sticking together in the roll)
Un-wrapped bullseyes. That creamy center mmmm.
A Marathon bar. Haven’t seen them in years ( decades ) though.
That’s a good one, hard to miss that mountain range. I’ve been buying the minis lately with only two peaks.
They are similar to Smarties, tho.
Kinder Eggs. By Ferrero.
If we can include wrapping, as they are egg-shaped plastic containing a hollow milk chocolate egg, The lawyer-enticing prize inside the chocolate egg makes them unavailable in the litigious USA, where ‘prize is not edible’ and/or “Prize may present a choking hazard” is meaningless.
How about marshmallow Peeps? Or just marshmallows?
Heath bars, if you still have your teeth. (If not, you can always suck on them.)
Starburst.
But could you tell them from Reese’s Pieces?