We buy toys–cheap plastic rings, toy soldiers, stuff that comes in sacks.
We don’t get many kids here, so we get this, which keeps on the shelves from year to year.
The kids like it. 
Yeah, but you can’t eat the leftovers if you buy toys…
We have black, orange, purple and green spider rings. We live in the middle of nowhere on a dead end road, so we don’t get any trick or treaters, the kids hand them out at school to their classmates in little goodie bags.