Like everyone else on the web, I get endless inspiring and funny videos emailed to me by well-meaning friends. But when I received this one from a lady I know http://www.andiesisle.com/creation/magnificent.html I decided that it was time to express the atheist viewpoint. Basically, the video shows a lot of pretty scenes and the song that accompanies it says there must be a God since there is so much beauty in the world. So this is my answer to this woman. Any comments?
Dear ______. Thank you very much. This is indeed a beautiful video, and I do appreciate receiving it.
However, since this is a free country and anyone, even the despised atheists, can express their viewpoint, I have to say that the theist argument that the singer makes really does not stand up to logical scrutiny. His argument seems to be that God must exist because there are beautiful things in the world.
I completely agree that beauty and wonder exist. I see them every day, and I appreciate them every day.
But what this song and its video have done is to cherry-pick a few beautiful scenes, string them together, and create the illusion that we are surrounded by beauty and goodness. Therefore, he argues, God must exist.
In the first place, beauty and goodness are relative terms. I have no evidence that my cat would find a waterfall beautiful. In the country, I have gone out in the early morning with my cats to watch the sun rise over the lake. While I am filled with the beauty of the spectacle, I see no evidence that they are in any way interested in it. They simply take advantage of the light to hunt for mice.
Which brings me to another point. If things that are good and beautiful (in human eyes) prove that a God exists, what are we to conclude about all the things that are not? My cat catches and eats a mouse as I am watching the sunrise. For my cat, I am sure this is a “good thing”. The mouse is a nursing mother with a litter of young, who are now going to starve to death somewhere in their burrow. As a human being I have compassion, and I would like to find the litter and give the young mice a quick, merciful death, but I have no idea where they are on the property.
The video shows beautiful forests, landscapes and oceans. But even as these scenes are being shot, there are people dying of horrible, painful diseases. Women are having their noses cut off or acid thrown in their faces in many third world countries. People are starving in east Africa because of droughts.There are earthquakes like the one that hit Haiti where thousands of innocent people are killed or injured. Some of these horrors are caused by humans (often acting in the name of religion) and some are so-called “acts of God”.
I could string together a whole video of all these “acts of God” and write a song about how this proves that there is no God, but guess what? The existence of both beauty and ugliness, pain and pleasure in our world prove nothing about the existence of God. Luckily, it is not up to atheists to prove God does not exist. It is up to theists to prove that there is a God. And this video full of selected scenes simply does not prove that.