Coincidentally, I have read about a few Jewish prisoners in the federal and state systems in the past few days. They were all in minimum security prisons for white collar crimes where such things wouldn’t exist much. I am not trying to be flip. Jews make up about 2% of the U.S. population and they aren’t known culturally for maximum security scumbag type crimes although the laws of large numbers still dictates that there are many spread across the various maximum security prison systems in the U.S.
I don’t know how you can isolate this question enough without getting hopelessly anecdotal because the specific circumstances would have to be very rare. Like always, I have a story of my own. I was in an (unnamed) support group 5 years ago with a true psycho that had just gotten out of the Massachusetts maximum security system for all types of crimes and he was a skinhead. He took a special hatred towards me right away and he seemed to have absolutely no redeeming qualities aside from loving his five year old son a great deal. He mentioned a few times that the mother of his son was Jewish and she had custody of the child. I happened to walk upon an informal smoke break with him and a few fellow scumbags in which he was literally showing various Arian nation and other white supremacy cards and literature. He hated Jews and blacks and everyone else. One look told you this was not the brightest or most rational little bulb.
I wasn’t trying to be inflammatory but I blurted out that his son was technically Jewish because his mother was. Uh-oh. That is ninja lesson #1 on how to drive a white supremacist instantly insane. Attempted violence instantly erupted but the man in question was addicted to opiates because of a bad back and hurt himself even worse in a classic gimp move. Authorities were called and the consequences were harsh against him (none against me).
Some of this may seem like irrelevant rambling but I assure you that it is not. People in maximum security prisons don’t usually have doctorates in philosophy. They just make things up to suit their needs. There are lots of categories of people that wouldn’t fit into a dichotomous system like you describe but people find a way to make things fit in their minds just like we all do in human group interractions.