The “dead or nearly dead tropes” thread just recently got bumped, and I noticed my own post in that thread about the old trope of the fancy restaurant where the menu is entirely in French. And that made me wonder if that was ever actually a thing. Was there a time when fine dining establishments in the US had menus written in French?
I could imagine at one time maybe educated upper class people were expected to know French, and I could see fancy restaurants writing their menus in French as a way of keeping out the unwashed masses. But was it actually a thing, or a creation of Hollywood?
Fine dining establishments often featured elaborate descriptions of dishes, sometimes in French, reflecting the perception of French cuisine as the height of culinary achievement. Menu design became an art form, with restaurants commissioning beautiful illustrations and typography to enhance the dining experience.
My memory is a little different - I think the trope was that all fancy restaurants were French , not that a fancy Italian restaurant /steakhouse had a menu written in French.
I’ve never been to a Michelin star restaurant but I do like to go to good places. I’ve been to multiple restaurants that have menus in Italian or in German. If there is a description it’s usually in English but if it’s just the name of the food and there is no attempt to translate the terms into English. I’m reasonably good at restaurant Italian and German but I’m happy to have Google at times like that.
It was both – the restaurants were French, and the menu was written in French. The trope was that the character was embarrassed to admit they couldn’t read French, so they would randomly point at something on the menu. Usually they would end up being brought escargot, like @Nars_Glinley mentioned. I also recall a variation where the snooty waiter would inform them that they were pointing at the dress code, or something else that isn’t food (which would imply that literally everything was in French, not just the names of the items).
I am more a gourmand than a gourmet, but once i did eat at one- right before it got its star. Tasty, great service, not worth the money- but someone else was paying.
If you like butter and garlic, escargot isnt bad. Not good mind you, but I ate it.
Crayfish can be damn good- Cajun Crawfish Etouffee is great.
In Jingo, Vimes figures out and has confirmed that the sheep eyeballs thing is a joke on newbs.
I’ve read a couple of English history books written in the 1950s that when quoting French people (and only French people) it would be entirely untranslated French for absolutely no reason.