[QUOTE=Cartooniverse]
No offense, but you could not be more incorrect. For quite a few years ( until very recently ), both of my brothers in law played Strads. Many of their contemporaries play either a Strad or a Guarnari.
Sure, there are some hotshots on the scene such as Sam Zygmuntowicz ( pronounced " Sigmantovich" ) whose instruments are regarded as brilliant jewels in the making ( time being the element one cannot force ). However, it is generally agreed that the Cremona violin makers of old created a body of work that has not be equalled since.
It is not the sizzle, it’s the steak. Sitting around during the holidays, the in-laws love to play Pick The Fiddle. When one of my brothers in law bought a Zygmuntowicz, they did a blind listen test. They had his Strad, my other brother in law’s Strad, the Zygmuntowicz, and two violins made by my wife’s grandfather in the 1940’s. ( He was a violinmaker by trade, not by hobby. ).
I am not a musician, and even I could immediately hear the difference in the instruments.
The Strad is the preferred instrument of those who have the pocketbook. One of the Strads in the family is considered a bastard instrument, because of repair work that was done. It’s worth is around 1.75 Mil. The other one, that is no longer in the family, was in remarkable shape. It was on long-term loan ( read: over 10 years ), and was returned finally. It was insured for over 3 Mil.
You are correct in believing that many Strads are purchased as investments by companies or Foundations
This article is a detailed discussion on what makes a Strad a Strad.
I did, at one point, ask to hold one and try to make a sound with it. It amused the hell out of the family. Clearly the artist component is crucial, even with a top-drawer instrument.
On the other hand, 20 years ago at my wedding, my (ex) sister-in-law from my side asked if she could see them both. She played violin in High School, and to her the chance to hold two Strads at once was too much to resist. They indulged her, of course. Then she played one for a while. Quite a treat to the trained ear, apparently. Which is why they are preferred by professional violinists…
Pushkin, all anecdotals aside, that last link I provided directly addresses your OP in some serious detail. Peruse it for answers. 
Cartooniverse
[/QUOTE]
So if the secret is indeed the varnish, we should see modern violins sounding SETTER than the 250±year old Stardivaris, Amtis, etc. This would seem to diminish the value of the geniune strds, would it not? kinda like what will happen when cheap, high-quality synthetic diamonds hit the mass market!