Cartman demands that you respect his authoriteh and answer this question!
Moving to Cafe Society from IMHO.
Woodland Critter Christmas gets my vote. I love the “twist” and how overly cutesy the animals are, even while being completely evil.
The last three, Red Sleigh Down, Christmas in Canada & Woodland Critter, were all so good that it’s hard to decide. As much as I loved the surprise ending to Christmas in Canada I still have to vote for Woodland Critter.
I think it was Mr. Hankey’s Christmas Classics that was terrible. Probably the worst South Park ever. It just didn’t even try to be funny. Maybe they were going for meta-humor, being just like a real godawful 70s Christmas special, but it still didn’t work.
Gotta go with the Woodland Critters.
“…and they all lived happily ever after. Except for Kyle, who died of AIDS three days later.”
Is that the one that’s all Christmas Carols? I loved that one, it’s my favorite ever…especially “Christmastime in Hell”
Hard to choose between “Red Sleigh Down” and “Woodland Critter Christmas,” but had to go with Red Sleigh Down.
“On Steven, on Fluffy…On Horace and Chantel…On Skippy, On Rainbow, Patches and Montel”
Woodland Critter Christmas, by a mile
Woodland Christmas is great, but it doesn’t beat the first reveal of Mr. Hankey. Granted, he loses his appeal once he’s used again, but that first moment was golden.
And they really only have Christmas specials half the time? Odd.