The “Hicks babies.” Dr. Thomas Hicks from McCaysville GA delivered babies, then sold them, possibly as many as 200. Many, if not all of the birth mothers were told that their baby didn’t survive.
Erik Larson also wrote The Devil in the White City, featuring two parallel stories, one about the design and construction of the 1893 World’s Columbian Exposition, and the other about one H.H. Holmes, who was probably America’s first serial killer, and who had a “murder castle” to which he lured his victims. It was an entertaining read, especially the part about the challenges of building the world’s fair. Both events were set in Chicago.
I listened to a podcast last night about the Amagasaki incident, a series of murders which occurred in Japan. In 2011, an elderly woman named Miyoko Sumida in the city of Amagasaki reported to police that her neighbor had mysteriously disappeared. She was found a few weeks later living in Osaka under an assumed name and refused to explain anything to police, so the police brought her home. Around the same time, workers clearing abandoned things out of a shuttered factory discovered the body of another elderly woman, who had been beaten to death and partially encased in concrete, who dental records identified as the mother of the woman who’d gone missing. When the police investigated the family, they found that the formerly missing woman, her sister, her sister’s ex-husband, and their two adult children were all living together in a small condo and were strangely thin and emaciated, and all of them nonsensically claimed that the mother had killed herself, though witness reports soon revealed that the family had been seen beating the mother in a public park.
It eventually turned out that Sumida, the elderly neighbor who had initially reported the woman missing was in fact a yakuza boss and sort of cult leader who would get families indebted to her and then take control of their entire lives, dictating when they could eat and sleep and bathe, and eventually start ordering them to kill each other and themselves, and that the murdered woman’s two daughters had beaten their own mother to death on her command. She ended up committing suicide in her cell before she could go to trial, but police wound up linking her to as many as 8 murders beginning in 1987.
The Wikipedia article on the case is a little difficult to read because most of the names of the people involved are redacted, but it’s quite a tale.
Okay, I looked this up, and it made me vaguely remember a story about a crooked OB who operated a facility that straddled two state lines, one state had more lax laws regarding adoptions, and that was the side the women whose babies he sold delivered on. I didn’t read the whole story; was it this one?
The Routier case, happened a couples blocks from us.
So I have always kept an eye on it.
I think it is likely she committed the murders, but I doubt I could have convicted her if I had been on the jury
“Isaac’s Storm”, about the 1900 Galveston hurricane? I’ve read it. Excellent book.
BTW, Erik Larson’s telling of the H. H. Holmes story has largely been debunked. Did he kill anyone? I think so. Did he do as many as this book says he did, and in those manners? Probably not.
I agree about Larson. I’ve read most of his books, with the notable exception of Lethal Passage because I thought I’d find the subject matter (about guns in America) too difficult to read about. The one about the hurricane is Isaac’s Storm, about the great hurricane that destroyed Galveston, and I can highly recommend it.
.
Do you have a cite for the debunking? It’s always been my impression that Larson’s research was pretty meticulous. Though I imagine that sometimes, for events that happened more than one and a quarter centuries ago, there may be disagreement on some of the details..
Mary Fager returned home from a business trip and found the body of her husband, who had been shot in the back. The bodies of her daughters, aged 9 and 16, were in the hot tub. One had been drowned in the tub, and the other had been strangled and then dumped into the tub. A few days later, Bill Butterworth, a handyman who had been building a sunroom to house the hot tub, was arrested in Florida, driving Mr. Fager’s car. He had emptied his bank account before leaving town.
The DA, in a rush to judgement, proceeded with undue haste to bring the case to trial. But a young public defender showed the flaws in the state’s case, and the jury found him not guilty.
The case cost the DA his job, and the public defender went on to become one of the best defense attorneys in the state. The case remains unsolved.
In An Underground Education, author Richard Zacks claims that Holmes did carry out a few murders in various insurance schemes and other crimes, but the tabloid press of the time inflated him into a monstrous serial murderer of 200 victims.
But … the Cecil Adams article you cite seems quite consistent with Erik Larson’s account of a crazed serial killer. For example:
[In 1890] he also began to build a “hotel” across the street. It was a gaudy three-story building with shops on the first floor and a bizarre labyrinth of windowless rooms, false floors, secret passages, trapdoors, and chutes above. Holmes changed contractors several times and shuffled the workers around frequently so that no one ever got a clear idea of the floor plan or what the building was for.
In fact it was a death house. Most of the rooms had gas vents that could only be controlled from a closet in Holmes’s bedroom. Many were soundproof and could not be unlocked from inside. A few rooms were lined with asbestos, presumably so the victim could be incinerated. Chutes and passages led to the basement, where Holmes had installed an oven for cremating the bodies as well as several lime pits for disposing of whatever evidence remained.
It’s been a while, but IIRC Larson presents the sensational popular story with a very skeptical eye. Holmes’s behavior, especially while ‘on the run’ with the girls he definitely killed, indicates narcissistic sociopath type, but not a crazed killer who did it for the thrill. He probably offed some witnesses and/or accomplices to his scams. Send to have sold skeletons to a medical school, à la Burke & Hale.
The “murder castle” is the dubious part. Letting vulnerable young women to the big city seems plausible, but a lot of work for little monetary reward.